
By Austin Snedden, Ranching Contributor, Valley Ag Voice
The cattle industry has seen several years of record prices. Sure, our input costs are also at record numbers, but undeniably, these have been good times for the cow-calf industry. The danger associated with these good times is that economic efficiency can be overlooked, and you are still in the black. I am not going to be the one to give a forecast of hard times ahead, but market variation has always been part of the cattle business. We need to keep our operations from developing bad habits now, even though we can afford them, lest we set ourselves up for challenging times when gross cattle income is not as high.
The price per head has doubled, possibly more than doubled, over the past five years, and it has been well deserved for this industry. Prior to the last five years, the cow calf industry experienced a relative flatline economically since 2005, which put many producers out of business, and many that sustained had to incur debt or defer needed capital improvements to the business. The recent record prices are justifiable based on the fact that the national cow herd is at its lowest numbers since the 60s, and we have not been flooded with as many imports as before. Although we have never seen prices like this, they are justified given the increased cost of inputs in our businesses. When you couple a contracted supply with the carnivore mania trend driving demand for the best protein in the world, you end up with record prices.
It is exciting and well-deserved returns for a very dedicated and hard-working industry, but it is important that we watch our bottom lines and not develop habits that are unsustainable when margins change.
Current prices may justify spending more on supplemental feed to run a few more cows or possibly get a few more underperforming cows to breed. With the current price per pound, maybe it makes sense to use genetics with more growth potential, even if it takes additional supplements to sustain those bigger frames. The long-term risk of either of these scenarios is that we end up artificially propping up inferior genetics that are not as efficient or suited to our environment. Artificially propping up inferior cows that would have been culled on a lesser market not only shrinks our margins in the future, but the act of pulling those cows along to get one more calf propagates those inferior genetics, and they become dispersed in your herd.
Maybe this market justifies keeping that cow with the bad udder around that you have to milk out every time she calves, or the cow with inferior maternal instincts that you have to pair up so she will accept her calf. Maybe you keep around those heifers and cows that need help calving, even though they would have been culled in a different market. All of these scenarios may be justifiable, but just be aware that you are propagating high-maintenance cattle.
Every operation must evaluate its own circumstances and determine the best path forward in today’s market to ensure long-term success. For some, that might mean paying down debt to create a more financially sustainable foundation. Others may choose to invest in infrastructure, such as water systems or cross fencing, to maximize the efficiency of their feed resources. Investing in improved working facilities that require less labor could also be a smart move, especially as labor costs continue to rise. There are many options for investing in future profitability. Be cautious not to let the current cattle market cause you to propagate inferior genetics that result in a high-maintenance cow herd in the future.









