cows grazing at sunset
Photo: Shutterstock.com
Cattlemans corner Austin Snedden

By Austin Snedden, Ranching Contributor, Valley Ag Voice 

When it comes to California’s Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA), have no fear–the folks who played a big role in creating the problem are here to fix it. When the State refused to deliver contracted, paid, and promised water through the State Water Project because of a worthless little fish, farmers and municipalities were forced to pump groundwater. When the pumping resulted in lowering groundwater levels and subsidence, the State decided to heap burdensome regulations on its productive citizens. The rational solution would have been to deliver water, as promised, instead of letting millions of gallons of fresh water flow into the ocean, but instead, we have SGMA. I think the fight should be with the State and their breach of contract on State Water Project deliveries, but nevertheless SGMA is here and we are left to wrestle amongst ourselves to figure out who gets what and who pays what.  

As a non-irrigated grazer, SGMA has thrust some of us into a predicament where it’s necessary to stand up for ourselves against folks we are usually allies with. This is a delicate situation that needs to be handled fairly so that folks don’t become disenfranchised. I am not here to indict irrigators or other major groundwater users, but rather to defend and protect non-irrigated grazers from a conflict they played no role in creating. The Kern Subbasin is made up of many different water districts and GSAs that all have to work in accordance to get the entire basin in compliance with SGMA. The area within the Kern Subbasin most pertinent to some cattle ranchers is the Kern Non-Districted Land Authority (KNDLA). Although the acronym “KNDLA” has the words “non-districted” represented in it, the KNDLA Board is not made up of stake holders from the non-districted area, but rather by the other water districts in the basin. The Kern County Water Agency (KCWA) has granted some level of authority over the non-districted lands to a group of individuals representing other districts. While this situation doesn’t seem like ideal governance, these other water districts, which have a significant stake in achieving State compliance, can potentially navigate this situation if they treat the non-districted stakeholders fairly.  

The only way this situation can be navigated fairly is to avoid making the folks whose land is a net positive to the basin pay for the folks who are extractors.  

Let’s talk about the science. A conservative estimate of the grazing ground in the non-districted area would have a stocking rate of one cow per fifteen acres (although much of the ground in the area would be 20-40 acres per cow). According to a University of Nebraska study, a cow will drink 10-50 gallons of water a day, depending on the temperature and stage of production. To not undervalue the water usage of a cow, I will use forty gallons a day. At 40 gallons a day, a cow will consume 14,600 gallons per year. At a stocking rate of one cow per 15 acres, a cow’s annual water consumption is 973 gallons per acre. The Kern non-districted area has been given a sustainable yield of 0.2 acre-feet per acre. 0.2 of an acre-foot is 65,170 gallons, meaning each acre in the non-districted area has been deemed to contribute 65,170 gallons to the basin annually. Even with a purposeful overestimate on stocking rate and cow water consumption, an acre of unirrigated native pasture used for cows contributes 67 times more water to the basin than that cow consumes.  

Every acre of non-irrigated grazing ground is a net benefit to the basin water situation–be sure not to penalize these folks with assessments, taxes, or fees. There may be a place and time for these non-irrigated grazing land owners to band together and sell their cumulative thousands of acre feet of sustainable yield credits to other parties in a very thirsty basin. To decision-makers, from now on, regarding non-districted grazing land, refrain from infringing on property rights and avoid making grazers pay for a problem they don’t contribute to. If you are planning a potluck, don’t charge admission to the person who brings all the food and doesn’t eat.  

Previous articleExecutive Director’s Report 
Next articleFarm Bureau Presidents Guide Kern Agriculture Through History