(Photo: Luliia Kovalova/Adobe Stock)

By Joshua Stevens, Faith Contributor, Valley Ag Voice

Perspicuity of Scripture. A scary phrase at first and somewhat comical when you learn it simply means that the Bible can be clearly understood by those who seek the truth. Sola Scriptura is the belief that the Bible is the only infallible authority by which a Christian should live. In this belief, Protestants proclaim that any ordinary person can read the Bible and come away with the gospel. They do not need an infallible church or ecumenical council to come to this conclusion. This does not imply that everything in the Bible is simple, clear, or easy to understand; it simply suggests that any reasonable person can grasp the gospel message. i

This belief directly contradicts what the Catholic church teaches about Scripture, with Catholic answers stating that, “It is much simpler to adopt the approach that the Church has in fact pursued—that is, to allow Scripture scholars liberty to interpret any Bible passage in whatever way they feel the evidence best supports provided certain minimal boundaries are not crossed.”ii Catholic Answers goes on to say that those minimal boundaries can change over time.

We must ask the question: Who is right? Do Christians require an infallible authority to interpret Scripture? This article will argue against the notion that Christians need an infallible authority to interpret Scripture for them. This will be demonstrated through three arguments: first, from Scripture itself, second, from history, and third, from reason. These arguments are supported by examples that demonstrate each ordinary person has both the capacity and ability to come to a clear understanding of what Scripture teaches, as well as to conclude which things are necessary to the faith. This article will also demonstrate how the Catholic Church, in exercising its authority, has unnecessarily added to the necessities of the faith, thereby breaking unity with fellow believers.

In Paul’s introduction in his letter to the Romans, he writes, “For what can be known about God is plain to them, because God has shown it to them. For his invisible attributes, namely, his eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly perceived, ever since the creation of the world, in the things that have been made. So they are without excuse.iii” Paul’s words are clear – God has created humanity in such a fashion that each of us can bear witness to, acknowledge, and respond to the things which God has made known to us through creation.

Yet God has not only spoken through nature; He also revealed Himself through Scripture. While Catholics include the deuterocanonical books as part of their canon, both Catholicsiv and Protestantsv accept the 66 books of the Protestant canon to be the divinely inspired word of God. God reveals Himself through the text of Scripture, so if God can use the stars, the trees, and the very breath of His creation to make known His power, how much more can He reveal through His Word?

A Catholic might argue that just as nature can be misinterpreted—leading to errors like atheism or belief in a flat earth—so too can Scripture be misread, resulting in false doctrines, such as denying Christ’s divinity or promoting the idea that God will always heal if we have enough faith. This is a valid concern; Scripture can be misinterpreted, just as nature can.

However, this does not establish the need for an infallible Church. It only demonstrates the need for a church and its elders to guide believers in sound doctrinevi, much like how scientific communities correct false interpretations of the natural world. In the same way that we do not require an infallible scientific authority to know the earth is round; we do not need an infallible Church to guard against misinterpretation. Any claim of infallibility must be supported by independent and persuasive evidence, rather than deemed necessary based on the possibility of error.

A clear understanding of Scripture can also be found in history. As we explored in “Tradition and Scripture” back in March, the first ecumenical council — the Council of Nicaea — relied on Scripture to build a case for the divinity of Christ. The council notably lacked the presence of the bishop of Rome, and the records from Nicea show that the fathers were arguing over the person of Christ based on the Scriptures. There was no appeal to the authority of any singular bishop, elder, or tradition other than those traditions which had been handed down in the form of Scripture.

The council of Nicaea set a precedent that would be kept by Protestants more than 1,500 years later, where in the fall of 1978, more than 300 evangelical scholars would gather and sign what is known as “The Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy.”vii This statement would define what biblical inerrancy meant to evangelicals throughout America for the next 50 years. In fact, you’d be hard-pressed to find a local nondenominational church that doesn’t reference and affirm the statement even today.

We do not need something infallible or even explicitly binding to have a governing authority in the church that guides us in doctrinal truth. No Christian is an island, and likewise, no congregation stands alone. The Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy is a powerful example that, even in modern times, Protestants can come together, setting aside secondary issues to converse, debate, and reach a conclusion that will guide the church in the decades to come.

This can be contrasted by the Second Vatican Council which, instead of uniting Christians amongst denominations, drove a wedge between Catholics and other Christians. Even more, it has become a dividing point for many Catholicsviii who are debating how to interpret the council.ix Despite the council being called to promote unity and renewal amongst Catholics, it has done the opposite. This issue must be addressed by Catholics who claim that the Papacy and the church at large must be infallible to guide Christians in what they believe. If this were true, there should be no reason to have such ongoing internal tension surrounding councils like Vatican II.

There is a stark contrast between the Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy and the Second Vatican Council. The Chicago Statement, though it claimed no infallible authority, carried no institutional enforcement power, and was entirely voluntary, has nonetheless shaped the doctrine of inerrancy for many evangelical churches and institutions for decades. By contrast, Vatican II—despite being promulgated by what Catholics claim is an infallible Magisterium—has remained a source of deep division within the Catholic Church for over 60 years, with ongoing debates about its interpretation and implementation. This highlights that infallibility does not guarantee doctrinal clarity or unity, and that meaningful doctrinal consensus is possible apart from claims of infallible teaching authority.

Tim Staples, a Catholic Answers Apologist, once answered the question, “Why be Catholic?” with this saying, “I became Catholic, first and foremost, to save my soul.”x He said this to someone who described themselves as a “born again Christian.” Tim explained that he accepted Christ at age 10 at a Baptist church, and he became a pastor at an Assemblies of God church before finally deciding that he should become a Catholic, as he believed it was not God’s will for us to have multiple denominations.

This brings us to our final argument: reason. Certain Catholics, such as Mr. Staples, believe that the only way to ensure we are saved is to become Catholic and believe everything from the trinitarian nature of God to Mary’s assumption into heaven.xi

We will posit an alternative method which operates both philosophically and theologically: any doctrine or belief required for salvation must be logically necessary and clearly taught in Scripture. Philosophically, if a belief is required, then its denial renders salvation impossible or incoherent. Theologically, Scripture is the authoritative source revealing these necessary truths. For example, belief in the Trinity is logically imperative because denying the triune nature of God means failing to know who God truly is, thereby invalidating one’s faith. Conversely, doctrines such as the Assumption of Mary, which have no logical connection to salvation and are not explicitly taught in Scripture, are rightly seen as non-essential to the gospel and saving faith.

This argument affirms the essentials of what other protestants have believed throughout history, such as the Westminster Confession of Faith. Still, it has been refined to address the specific disagreements Protestants have with Catholics and should be used only for matters of doctrinal triage or discerning what beliefs are core to the faith and what are non-essential doctrines.

With that note, this argument demonstrates that the mandatory belief in Mary’s Assumption represents a development in Catholic doctrine that goes beyond the essentials of the gospel. Since Catholics are required to assent to all formally defined dogmas under the risk of heresy,xii the inclusion of Mary’s Assumption as a dogma effectively adds to the essentials of salvation beyond what Scripture and logical necessity require.

This can be summarized in the following syllogism:

Premise 1: Only doctrines that are logically necessary for salvation and clearly taught in Scripture are essential parts of the gospel.

Premise 2: The doctrine of Mary’s Assumption is neither logically necessary for salvation nor taught in Scripture.

Conclusion: Therefore, the doctrine of Mary’s Assumption is not an essential part of the gospel and represents an addition beyond the gospel.

Over the past year, we have published 12 articles written for individuals who are grappling with ecumenical angst over which church they should be a part of. I hope these articles have given anyone wrestling with those doubts encouragement and confidence in the faith we share. I hope these articles have inspired those of more ecumenical traditions, such as Catholics and Orthodox, to think through some of these issues in a different way.

Will you pray with me?

Dear Lord,

Thank You for the opportunity You have given us to spend the last year thinking, reading, writing, and discussing the work You have continued to do through the church here on Earth. Thank You for the role each of us get to have in that work. We ask that you continue to guide us in truth and love for one another. Give us the courage to seek first Your will and kingdom in our lives. In Jesus’ mighty name,

Amen.

References:

i. “Chapter 1.7.” Reformation21.org, 2025, www.reformation21.org/confession/2013/01/chapter-17.php. Accessed 26 June 2025.

ii. “The Limits of Scripture Interpretation.” Catholic Answers, www.catholic.com/magazine/print-edition/the-limits-of-scripture-interpretation.

iii. The Holy Bible: English Standard Version (Wheaton, IL: Crossway Bibles, 2016), Ro 1:19–20.

iv. “Catechism of the Catholic Church.” Usccb.cld.bz, 2024, usccb.cld.bz/Catechism-of-the-Catholic-Church/42/.

v. The Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy.

vi. The Holy Bible: English Standard Version (Wheaton, IL: Crossway Bibles, 2016), Tt 2:1–15

vii. The CHICAGO STATEMENTS on INERRANCY and HERMENEUTICS. (2014). Defending Inerrancy. https://defendinginerrancy.com/chicago-statements/

viii. catholicus. (2025, January 19). Internal Controversies in the Church Regarding the Second Vatican Council: Understanding the Debate from a Catholic Perspective. Catholicus.eu English. https://catholicus.eu/en/internal-controversies-in-the-church-regarding-the-second-vatican-council-understanding-the-debate-from-a-catholic-perspective/

ix. Chapp, L. (2023, December 29). The Unresolved Debate: What Is the Proper Interpretation of Vatican II? NCR; National Catholic Register. https://www.ncregister.com/commentaries/the-unresolved-debate-what-is-the-proper-interpretation-of-vatican-ii

x. Staples, T. (2020). Why Should I Be Catholic? Catholic Answers. https://www.catholic.com/video/why-should-i-be-catholic

xi. Munificentissimus Deus (November 1, 1950) | PIUS XII. (n.d.). Www.vatican.va. https://www.vatican.va/content/pius-xii/en/apost_constitutions/documents/hf_p-xii_apc_19501101_munificentissimus-deus.html

xii. Dogma. (n.d.). Catholic Answers. https://www.catholic.com/magazine/print-edition/dogma

Previous articleSave-the-Date for these Agricultural Events  
Next articleKern Subbasin Looks to Avoid Probation with New Plan