Few delta smelt remain in the wild
Delta smelt. (Photo: University of California, Davis)

By Scott Hamilton, President, Hamilton Resource Economics 

Delta smelt have been featured in several front-page stories in Valley Ag Voice over the last several years. This is partly because this little fish has cost farmers in the Valley hundreds of thousands of acre-feet nearly every year since measures were implemented to offset Water Project impacts in 2008, and partly because the science supporting some of those measures was weak at best.   

Since 2008, operations of the Central Valley Project and State Water Project have been governed in part by regulations to protect endangered fish, including salmon and delta smelt. In 2016, the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation requested reinitiation of consultation to update water project operations based on new information and science that had emerged since 2008. The USFWS Service completed its Biological Opinion in 2019, approving the proposed water project operations.  

The proposed water project operations included potential “Summer/Fall Smelt Habitat actions,” increasing releases of water from reservoirs intended to benefit delta smelt and increase their food supply. The actions were to be studied in a science-based framework, known as structured decision making, to evaluate how the actions could be best implemented.   

In the fall of last year, Governor Newsom stepped in to suspend one of the proposed actions included within the Summer/Fall Smelt Habitat set of actions because the science at the time showed no benefit to delta smelt.  

Since then, several structured decision-making processes have been completed.  The word on the street is that neither the California Department of Water Resources nor the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation is proposing implementation of Summer/Fall Habitat Actions in 2025 based on their review of the science. Whether those recommendations survive the political process is yet to be seen.  Still, many environmental organizations want to see increased flows through the Delta and out to the Pacific Ocean.  The ability for sound science to prevail despite political pressure is an important win for resource management. 

The ability for sound science to prevail was due in part to numerous farmers and water districts in Kern County who, for many years now, have financially supported science-based efforts to improve water management in California.  The organization leading this scientific effort is the Center for California Water Resources Policy and Management (calwatercenter.org). The Center has sponsored scientists who have published their findings in national and international journals and have provided science-based support for resource management decisions. Included in that work was a thorough review of Summer/Fall Habitat Actions, which found no benefit of the actions for delta smelt, and presentation of those findings to water managers in Sacramento.  In the complex and often confounding world of California water, the Center provides a unique resource. 

Previous articleWolf Recovery Comes at a High Cost for California Ranchers 
Next articleCalifornia Almond Growers Expect Higher Yields in 2025