groundwater
(ARCHIVE Photo: Shutterstock.com)

By Valley Ag Voice Staff 

Since the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act’s enactment in 2014, its impact on California’s groundwater management has unfolded gradually. However, a true turning point occurred in April 2024, when the Tulare Lake Subbasin — one of seven critically overdrafted basins — underwent its probationary hearing and was subsequently placed on probation. 

This marked the first time the state exercised its enforcement authority under SGMA. According to a May article by the professional law corporation Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Ruud & Romo, SGMA implementation has reached a critical juncture.  

The seven critically overdrafted basins deemed inadequate by the Department of Water Resources include the Tulare Lake Subbasin, Tule Subbasin, Kaweah Subbasin, Kern County Subbasin, Delta-Mendota Subbasin, Chowchilla Subbasin, and Pleasant Valley Subbasin. 

This critical juncture has prompted closer scrutiny of the seven overdrafted basins now facing direct state oversight. 

TULARE LAKE SUBBASIN 

As the first subbasin to face a probationary hearing, the Tulare Lake Subbasin set a precedent for several newly unfolding processes, including successful litigation against the State Water Resources Control Board.  

After the SWRCB placed the subbasin on probation, the Kings County Farm Bureau filed a lawsuit to challenge the litigation, temporarily halting state enforcement activities — metering, reporting, and fee requirements — with a preliminary injunction in September 2024. The SWRCB appealed this injunction to the Fifth District Court of Appeal, and oral argument is pending.  

According to the AALRR report, the Tulare Lake Subbasin was designated as probationary in April 2024. Under normal circumstances, the SWRCB may impose an interim groundwater management plan if deficiencies remain unaddressed after one year. However, ongoing litigation has disrupted this timeline, introducing significant uncertainty about the extent of the Water Board’s authority in managing probationary basins. 

TULE SUBBASIN 

The Tule Subbasin was the second basin to be designated as probationary by the SWRCB in September 2024. However, this designation included limited exemptions from certain fees and reporting requirements for the Kern-Tulare Water District and Delano-Earlimart Irrigation District, recognizing their existing local groundwater management efforts. 

Still, all non-exempt groundwater extractors were required to begin measuring extractions by January 1, 2025. Compliance milestones are set through 2026, and Tule Subbasin groundwater sustainability agencies are continuing to submit revised GSPs to address deficiencies.  

In other developments, the Tule Subbasin continues to deal with internal disputes, and a new groundwater agency — the twelfth for the basin — was formed in February 2025. Farmers raised concerns about limited representation on the new agency, which is a joint effort between the Porterville Irrigation District and the City of Porterville, leading to the creation of a grower stakeholder group.  

This new agency was formed after parts of the Eastern Tule GSA broke away amid ongoing issues and a lawsuit from Friant Water Authority.  

The FWA has alleged that Eastern Tule gave too many groundwater credits to farmers, causing subsidence, and is now seeking fees from the breakaway districts. According to SJV Water, farmers are concerned that this dispute could jeopardize their ability to gain exemptions from state water regulations. 

KAWEAH SUBBASIN 

The Kaweah Subbasin continues to be a “grade A” student, and the SWRCB canceled its probationary hearing in January 2025 after local GSAs submitted amended plans and demonstrated progress.  

This cancellation allows time for a thorough review of the revised GSPs submitted earlier in the year. 

REGIONAL SUBSIDENCE PLAN 

Water managers for Tulare Lake, Tule, and the Kaweah subbasins are exploring the idea of creating a joint regional plan to monitor and reduce land subsidence — the sinking of land caused by excessive groundwater pumping. 

The proposed collaboration would help coordinate efforts across the three subbasin boundaries, since subsidence in one area can affect infrastructure and groundwater management in another.  

While initially discussed in March 2025, the urgency to act has grown as new subsidence guidelines from DWR are anticipated. During a June 3 Water Board meeting, Deputy Director for Sustainable Water Management at DWR Paul Gosselin explained that new guidelines will employ a more interactive process with GSAs.  

A release of the draft guidelines is anticipated soon, but no official date is available.  

KERN SUBBASIN  

The Kern County Subbasin, the largest groundwater subbasin in California, began its probationary hearing in February 2025, where the Water Board acknowledged local progress but continued the hearing to September to allow time for a revised GSP, which was due on June 20.  

GSAs were given additional time to effectively address remaining deficiencies, including declining groundwater levels, water quality degradation, monitoring networks, land subsidence, and the establishment of minimum thresholds for groundwater levels. 

DELTA-MENDOTA SUBBASIN 

The Delta-Mendota Subbasin originally encompassed 22 GSAs and seven GSPs, but it has since submitted a new, single consolidated GSP. The SWRCB is currently reviewing the revised GSA, and a probationary hearing date has not been made publicly available.  

CHOWCHILLA SUBBASIN  

On June 3, the Chowchilla Subbasin became the first to be sent back under DWR’s jurisdiction, successfully reversing course from potential probationary status. The four GSAs submitted a revised GSP in April and received a positive staff assessment on their progress.  

PLEASANT VALLEY SUBBASIN  

The Pleasant Valley Subbasin is the newest addition to the SWRCB’s review, with DWR deeming its GSP inadequate in February 2025.  

According to DWR, the GSP did not sufficiently address key issues related to groundwater levels, overdraft, and water quality. Specifically, it lacked clear and complete information on how groundwater level management would impact other indicators, did not reasonably assess or plan to mitigate overdraft, and narrowly defined water quality impacts by focusing too much on pistachios and omitting other uses, preventing DWR from determining if the Plan can achieve sustainability. 

While the subbasin does not possess a critically overdrafted designation, it is now under the Water Board’s review for potential state intervention.  

SGMA IN THE NEXT DECADE 

The next phase of SGMA implementation will continue to be defined by intensive litigation, increased pressure on GSAs to deliver measurable results, and higher stakes for enforcement.  

With over a decade under its belt, the era of SGMA planning is ending as the focus shifts to implementation, accountability, and real-world outcomes for California’s groundwater landscape. 

Previous articleThe Story Behind the Kern Water Bank 
Next articlePresident’s Message