By Austin Snedden, Ranching Contributor, Valley Ag Voice
In April, the Trump administration imposed reciprocal tariffs on imported products from several nations. The conventional opinion of legacy economists is generally negative towards tariffs.
Economists look at the national and global economy as third-party observers, as they should, making theories and observations based on supply and demand and human psychology. Five expert economists may weigh in with five separate opinions on one issue. The reason this can justifiably happen is that macroeconomics is comprised of a myriad of variables, and each variable’s role in the economic equation can be estimated differently. The factor that weighs into economics with the highest level of variability is human psychology and emotion. In my opinion, the study of macroeconomics dances somewhere between science and art, and thus, numerous different outcomes can be forecasted. When it comes to economists pontificating, I would contend that trading thoughts is simpler than goods and services.
To wrap my head around the tariff discussion, I dove into the realm that almost all cattle producers are familiar with. To get an understanding of things, I often try to distill something that I know only a little bit about into something I know a lot about. Cattle markets are a great snapshot of economics because of the many marketing options and the capitalistic principles that connect producers, marketers, processors, and consumers. (This is only true if we don’t fall victim to vertical integration, but I digress). Supply, demand, trading options, and timing variables make the cattle industry ripe for a fair-to-middling writer to make a metaphor.
Sure, I don’t know tariffs, but I do know commissions. I can avoid paying a commission to a livestock marketer, just as a foreign exporter can avoid paying a tariff. I can find a buyer and sell calves off the ranch, pay no commission to a marketer, and pocket the proceeds. The downside of this is that I don’t receive competitive bidding; even if I get multiple bids, my cattle still aren’t going to be presented in front of multiple buyers at the same time to drive competition.
Another option is to ship (or export, for the sake of the analogy) my calves to an auction market and sell them there. At the auction market, I am going to pay a commission (tariff), but my calves are going to be presented to multiple buyers, creating competitive bidding. Opening the door to more buyers is the primary benefit, but that commission is also paying for the infrastructure in pens, scales, water, power, and a comfortable place for buyers to bid on your cattle. The infrastructure of the pens allows a lot of cattle to be stored and, therefore, an attractive place for buyers to come and do commerce. This infrastructure took a lot of capital to build and a lot of capital to maintain, thus, the price of access to those additional buyers comes with a commission.
Don’t read this as a marketing guide for selling your cattle, but rather try to put together the disjointed concepts that I used to see a correlation to the tariff discussion. The United States is the premier market in the world for people to sell goods and services. A large part of why we are the premier market in the world is the costly infrastructure we have built that helps promote commerce domestically and therefore builds wealth, making US consumers the most sought-after consumers in the world. That costly infrastructure, which is a large part of making us an attractive market, has been built on the back of domestic production; maybe it is justified to require foreign interests to pay in order to reap the benefits of what we have built. If the commission rate doesn’t justify the market opportunity, sell the calves off the ranch, but if you willingly pay a commission to sell your calves because it opens your product up to a broader market, I would argue you don’t totally disagree with the concept of tariffs.









