(Photo: Gaetano/Adobe)

By Joshua Stevens, Faith Contributor, Valley Ag Voice 

Over several years, Trent Horn and others have listed several problems they believe should give pause to anyone who professes Protestantism. He focuses on two main issues: first, an issue with sola scriptura, and second, what he calls the Protestant creed problem.1 This article will detail Horn’s arguments, while subsequent articles will go through the issues one at a time to provide a defense for Protestantism.  

In Horn’s 2022 article and video, Horn begins his argument with a foundational question: in Protestantism, how do you know what the bare essentials are for Christianity and what belief or beliefs would cause someone to be outside the Christian faith? He correctly defines sola scriptura as being the only infallible source of authority for a Protestant. He then makes the following claim: “If scripture is the highest or ultimate authority for Christians or the only infallible authority, Protestantism has long concluded, has long affirmed, I should say, that there is no authority that has the unique responsibility to interpret scripture.” ​​He contrasts this position with the Catholic view that the magisterium has been placed in charge of the teaching of scripture. Horn’s first question to Protestants is, “Do Protestants agree on the ‘main things’?” and his second would follow, “Does the Bible explicitly reveal the ‘main things’?” 

Horn contends that Protestants disagree on major issues, and these disagreements show that protestants can’t agree on the essentials of Christianity; the problems he brings up are: Can Christians lose their salvation? Does baptism save infants? Can Christians deny sola scriptura or sola fida? Can Protestants truly hold to church tradition for teaching? Are Catholics Christian? Horn posits these questions should be answered within scripture and uniformly amongst Protestants.  

More recently, in response to the Southern Baptist Convention’s inability to adopt the Nicene creed, Horn posted an article about the problem Protestants have with creeds. He touched on this in his 2022 article, though this one focuses on the issues specifically with creeds in Protestantism. Horn goes on to show Protestants using the creeds and early councils as guardrails to keep us within the bounds of orthodoxy while we read and interpret scripture. He says this position is incoherent as it ends up  two ways: either you start in solo scriptura or “So it fails in one of two ways. First, if this whole paradigm treats scripture, the creeds, and the early church as being equal in authority, then it’s not sola scriptura. Because if sola scriptura is true, these sources cannot be equal in authority because sola scriptura says that scripture is the only infallible authority.”2 

He goes on to prove this, saying that if you can’t hold to Arianism because Nicaea condemns Arianism, then ecumenical councils hold equal authority to scripture, and as a result, sola scriptura is undermined and voided. He continues to say that if ecumenical councils are to be treated as guardrails, then they must have “binding authority” so that no one individual’s interpretation can go outside the guardrails.  

Horn also says it would be impossible for these creeds to have authority if modern Christians reinterpret these councils and decrees, citing an issue with baptismal regeneration in the Nicene Creed going back to his intro regarding the Southern Baptist Convention not adopting the Nicene Creed. Ending his article by saying, “So the only way one can say as a Baptist that their faith rhymes with old time religion is if you radically reinterpret what the ancient church believed so that you can disregard what they actually believed.”2 

Protestants must be able to wrestle and contend with these issues Horn has brought up. If he is right, Protestants have to rethink much of their dogma or perhaps even abandon their tradition. However, this article is not written so that Protestants may lose faith or be disheartened. Over the next few months, these articles will go through and address these points so Protestants can have confidence in the faith we hold.  

Will you pray with me? 

Thank you, Lord, for granting us all the opportunity to think, reason, and speak–that we may discuss with each other the most important of things and, by doing so, draw closer to you and the truth that has been revealed. Over these next many months, guide us each as we read and write to defend the faith you have given us, grant us humility that we may admit when we are wrong, and the love to embrace the truth you reveal for us all. In Jesus’ holy name we pray,  

Amen.  

Bibliography 

1 Horn, T. (2022, April 19). One Question Protestants can’t answer. Retrieved from Catholic Answers: https://www.catholic.com/audio/cot/one-question-protestants-cant-answer 

2 Horn, T. (2024, June 19). The Protestant, “Creed Problem”. Retrieved from Catholic Answers: https://www.catholic.com/audio/cot/the-protestant-creed-problem 

Previous articleState Water Board Adopts Permanent Water Restrictions  
Next articleSave-the-Date for these Agricultural Events