By Natalie Willis, Reporter, Valley Ag Voice
The California Department of Food and Agriculture, State Water Resources Control Board and Regional Water Quality Control Boards, and the California Environmental Protection Agency are nearing the completion of their Regulatory Alignment Study, with the final report expected in December.
The study was funded by the State in 2022 through the Budget Act, as a means to improve the regulatory system for farmers and ranchers. Public comment on the final draft report closed in October 2025.
According to the draft report released in September, CDFA contracted with Crowe LLP and their partner, Blankinship & Associates to conduct the study, developing 18 recommendations that utilize insight and interviews from producers, agency staff, and other interested parties across California.
The study focuses on regulatory alignment across select program areas: Produce Safety Program, Irrigated Lands Regulatory Program, Confined Animal Facility Program, and the Winery Order. While the program areas have varied priorities and structures, the draft report explained that they share common processes including enrollment, reporting, monitoring, inspection, and enforcement. Taken together, they represent a large portion of the food safety and water quality regulatory environment for California agriculture.
Over 80 requirements across the PSP, ILRP, CAF Program, and the Winery Order were analyzed. Additionally, federal rules, such as the United States Food and Drug Administration Produce Safety Rule and United States Environmental Protection Agency’s Clean Water Act, and state laws, such as the California Water Code, Food and Agricultural Code, and specific permits and orders were reviewed.
In the draft study’s foreword, CDFA Secretary Karen Ross explained that the purpose of the study focused on one guiding question: How can our State’s food safety and water quality regulations, requirements, and processes work better for agriculture while still delivering on our responsibility to protect the environment and public health?
COMPLIANCE COSTS
While not the primary purpose of the Regulatory Alignment Study, the issue of compliance costs was increasingly cited as a major barrier for producers.
“These costs often go beyond dollars. Producers described the need to hire consultants, maintain separate records for regulatory programs, and navigate multiple systems without support,” the draft report stated. “This was especially true for small and diversified farms, where reporting complexity and fragmented systems add strain.”
Several factors continue to hinder the industry including rising production costs, labor expenses and availability, higher interest rates, extreme weather events, and regulatory requirements.
“While food safety and water quality compliance costs account for a fraction of total indirect costs for many producers, regulatory requirements continue to evolve, creating continued pressures particularly for producers who lack the time, bandwidth, or support to navigate these evolving regulatory requirements alone,” the draft report stated.
Thus, the report asserts that regulatory alignment has the potential to simplify compliance through streamlined processes, improved data sharing, and more consistent requirements across programs.
PRETTY RECOMMENDATIONS
September’s draft report includes 18 recommendations organized into three categories — Foundational, Developmental, and Transformational Opportunities. The recommendations include an overview of the opportunity, a proposed solution, and specific implementation steps.
The Foundational Opportunities category features five recommendations, primarily focused on immediate actions that would support greater alignment across food safety and water quality programs, with a focus on grower outreach and education.
For instance, the first recommendation is for the CDFA to establish a Small Farm Regulatory Support Liaison through its Farm Equity Office to support small-scale “socially-disadvantaged” producers in navigating regulatory requirements. According to the report, the Liaison would offer full-time regulatory support for producers.
Other recommendations focus on technical assistance, data preparation support, and supporting local agencies in becoming authorized Local Agency Oversight Programs.
The second category, Developmental Opportunities, includes seven recommendations that outline long-term solutions to improve data systems, streamline reporting, and support regional implementation to simplify compliance.
One recommendation covering the Winery Order explains that wineries must meet ongoing monitoring requirements, and some facilities may need to prepare detailed Salt or Nitrogen Control Plans if monitoring shows potential water quality concerns. These plans can be time-consuming, requiring operators to analyze their treatment systems, assess water quality impacts, and potentially upgrade their facilities. To offer a more flexible option, the Winery Order allows wineries to meet these requirements through participation in a Water Boards-approved sustainability program, rather than developing site-specific control plans.
The California Sustainable Winegrowing Alliance expressed interest in expanding its program to meet Winery Order criteria, and the Water Boards support this effort, according to the draft report.
The report asserts that an accepted, industry-run sustainability program could reduce workload for Water Boards staff, provide participating wineries with a 10% annual fee discount, and strengthen water quality protection by helping operators understand and implement best practices for managing salt and nitrogen.
The last six recommendations are part of the Transformational Opportunities category, which outlines long-term solutions that build on existing state efforts to modernize and align food safety and water quality regulations.
One recommendation — Enhance Agricultural Permit Navigation with a Digital Decision Support Tool — asserts that producers face a confusing web of permits and regulatory requirements across multiple agencies and it can be a struggle to find a clear starting point.
While the existing CalGOLD website offers basic permit information, it lacks agricultural specificity, up-to-date descriptions, and guided support. They recommend expanding this tool into a modern, agriculture-focused support system to give producers step-by-step guidance based on operation type and location, helping them identify which permits apply and how to enroll.
To review the 18 recommendations in their entirety, visit CDFA’s website, www.cdfa.ca.gov/RegulatoryAlignment/, and review the draft Final Recommendations and Implementation Steps, released in September 2025.
Whether these recommendations result in tangible outcomes is yet to be determined, as the real test is whether these strategies translate from paper to practice. Time will tell if the significant resources invested in developing the recommendations will improve operations for the state’s farmers and ranchers, or if they will become a well-intentioned but unfulfilled plan.









