By Joshua Stevens, Faith Contributor, Valley Ag Voice
The doctrine of Sola Fide — by faith alone — was a rallying cry from the Protestant Reformation. This article will serve as an introduction to Sola Fide while subsequent articles will attempt to prove the concept. Though the reformers did not use this precise term, it is a concept to describe one of the central conflicts of the reformation and how Protestants and Catholics continue to differ to this day.
Sola Fide is essentially a slogan referring to someone’s justification before the Lord. The Protestant perspective on this issue can be laid out as follows: all humans are sinners in desperate need of a savior to unite them with God. On our own, we are incapable of overcoming our sinful state, separating us from God. Because of this, Christ entered the world through the virgin Mary, lived a sinless life, was crucified for the remission of our sins, and was resurrected three days later.
Confessing belief in these truths and placing faith in Christ alone is the only means in which someone can be justified before God. The Holy Spirit will enter a believer’s life and begin to affect change in him or her. That change will result in one’s sanctification — that is, the lifelong process of becoming more like Christ.
The visible marks of this change can be shown through baptism, fruits of the spirit, and good works. These visible marks, alongside one’s confession of faith, are outward signs for other believers that someone is a Christian. However, these signs are not what assure us inwardly of salvation or reconciliation with God.
Justification, as discussed in the New Testament, implies legal standing. Where we were once in sin and condemned by that sin to eternal separation from God, we are now adopted into God’s family.
Wayne Grudem, author and theologian, defines justification as “an instantaneous legal act of God in which he (1) thinks of our sins as forgiven and Christ’s righteousness as belonging to us, and (2) declares us to be righteous in his sight.”1 This definition is commonly referred to as “extrinsic righteousness,” wherein righteousness is given to us or believed to be in our account. Think of it this way: while still sinners, we are covered in the filth of our sin. Once we accept Christ, He gives us a coat to wear. So that when God looks upon us, he does not see our sin but Christ’s perfection. This analogy is not perfect, but it serves the purpose of showing how this process takes place.
In November of 2023, Catholic apologist Trent Horn called Sola Fide an “unworkable doctrine” before going on to ask a two-part question: First, what good works accompany genuine faith? And second, how many of these good works will accompany a person with true faith?2
To answer the first part of Horn’s question, one could look at the very text of scripture where these things are discussed. For example, Galatians 5:16-25 contrasts the work of the flesh with the fruit of the spirit, identifying evidence of a transformed life. Similarly, 1 John 2 explains that we come to know Christ by obeying His commands and warns that if we do not love our brothers, we remain in darkness. While these are not the only examples in the New Testament, they provide sufficient evidence of what someone should be looking for when evaluating the authenticity of a person’s confession.
For the second part of the question—how many good works must someone do?—I see no reason there should be a concrete answer to this. It’s akin to asking, “How many apples must this apple tree produce in order to be considered a ‘real’ apple tree?” or “How much heat must the sun produce in order to be considered a ‘real’ star?”
If an apple tree fails to bear fruit one year due to disease, weather, or isolation, is it no longer an apple tree? If the sun does not provide heat on any given day because of the clouds blocking it, does that mean it ceases to be a star? Certainly not! For it is the very nature of an apple tree to produce apples, and of stars to produce light and heat. So, it is the same for a believer to produce good works since it is in their very nature to do so. Not in their sinful nature, but in their justified nature being renewed in Christ and given the Holy Spirit as a partner in their sanctifying process.
Now, I’d like to pose a question for Horn and other Catholics who espouse this line of thinking. At what point in time does a good work consider to be a ‘good’ work? If a man decides to go to the store to buy his wife flowers, how far into that work must he get before he has done a good thing?
In order to be successful, he must first make it to the store, second find flowers his wife will enjoy, third purchase the flowers, fourth make it back with the flowers, and fifth give his wife the flowers. If he, however, is unable to make it home because a careless cyclist knocks him down, smashing the vase and trampling the flowers, does this mean the man did not do a good work? Or because he completed most of the work, has he done a good work? Or was the good work the very intent in attempting to do the work, and so it doesn’t matter how far along the man gets in the process, just that he earnestly attempted to do so?
For the Catholic this should pose a major problem. A problem that will be expounded on in my next article.
Will you pray with me?
Dear Lord,
Thank you for the opportunity you have given us to engage deeply with Your word and will. The faculties You have provided for us to think and reason. Our ability to so thoroughly communicate with one another in our attempt to strive in truth and together finish the race you have given us faithfully and well. Please provide for each of us clarity, comfort, and certainty so we may espouse only those things which are true and point both our family in Christ and those who are still lost towards You and Your coming kingdom. Amen.
1 Wayne Grudem, Systematic Theology: An Introduction to Biblical Doctrine, Second Edition. (Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan Academic, 2020), 885.
2 My Big Question for Defenders of ‘Sola Fide.’” 2023. Catholic Answers. 2023. https://www.catholic.com/audio/cot/my-big-question-for-defenders-of-sola-fide.









