By Joshua Stevens, Faith Contributor, Valley Ag Voice
“It has always therefore been one of my main endeavors as a teacher to persuade the young that firsthand knowledge is not only more worth acquiring than secondhand knowledge, but is usually much easier and more delightful to acquire.”i
C.S. Lewis’ introduction to a translation from St. Athanasius Lewis pens a picture nearly as beautiful as the saint himself when describing the implicit need for all to read directly from the source.
The assumed belief that all those who lived as “Christians” before the modern century are not worth studying has become a scourge amongst evangelicals today. It has led to a sad state of affairs in the Body of Christ. This denial of tradition has led to the wandering of sheep, the loss of souls into the kingdom, and weak Christians unprepared for life in the modern era. Too many evangelicals, though certainly not all, are unnecessarily wary of tradition. They raise an eyebrow when someone quotes Aquinas or any anti-Nicene father. They cling to the Bible as if God Himself had come down from heaven to hand them the book already translated, bound, and bookmarked for them.
Perhaps the most recent example of this can be seen in Ted Cruz’s reference to Genesis 12 in his interview with Tucker Carlson.ii Senator Cruz states that Genesis 12:3 reads, “ I will bless those who bless you, and him who dishonors you I will curse, and in you all the families of the earth shall be blessed.” In a section where God is speaking to Abram, God must be referring to the modern nation-state of Israel, and this belief is widespread among the modern evangelical movement. Although they can point to the Bible and the “plain reading” thereof, there is a noticeable lack of historical precedent for such a belief.
It’s not like Israel wasn’t a nation constantly trying to gain its independence. After all, the Temple was destroyed in 70 AD specifically because the Jews attempted to oust the Roman government and have a nation of their own.iii You would think that somewhere between when the first Christians started writing and the late nineteenth century, someone would have argued we should fight to make Israel a nation again because God blesses those who bless Israel.
However, this idea didn’t exist for the first nineteen hundred years of Christian history. This belief, that the modern nation-state of Israel is analogous to the Old Testament people of Israel, is typically held alongside a belief called dispensationalism, which is “an evangelical theological system that addresses issues concerning the biblical covenants, Israel, the church, and end times.”iv However, this system did not emerge until late in the nineteenth century; even its proponents claim it can be traced to only the sixteenth century.v This is where the underlying issue lies, and any notion of attaching Israel as a modern nation state to its Old Testament name is nowhere to be found in dispensationalism’s foundations.
People who believe they can live their lives in total confidence with nothing but a Bible are fooled into willfully separating themselves from the historic Body of Christ. It seems as though a serious case of memory loss has stricken the evangelical movement. For they seem to forget where they came from, how they arrived, or who helped them along the way.
When I previously wrote about Sola Scriptura, an entire section was dedicated to showing that the first people to believe in a proto-Sola Scriptura were not the reformers, but the earliest Christians! Examples exist from Saint Ignatius, the first council of Nicaea, and others.vi This practice is something the reformers regularly did; they didn’t believe in “my Bible and me.” They believed in a living and triumphant church, one that needed to be pruned so that the Body of Christ may shed those beliefs that have been needlessly added and continue as an effective witness to God and His glory in future generations.
This is what modern Evangelicals need today: a thorough examination of the movement, both nationally and locally, to identify what has been successful and what has not. To reform those things that have hurt the body and hindered spreading the gospel, and to rejoice for the things that have succeeded in fulfilling that great commission, which we were tasked with.
Over the next several months, we will publish the conclusion to our response to Catholicism and begin to examine how the Evangelical movement has succeeded, failed, and what it needs to change to continue impacting the kingdom to come in the next generation.
Will you pray with me?
Dear Lord,
Thank you for the opportunity you have given us to write, read, think, and discuss. The ability to reason with one another that we might have the opportunity to devout the entirety of our being to your glorification and the love of others through our words, thoughts, actions, and lives. Thank you for the freedom we have to debate such topics vigorously and without fear of persecution from the state. We ask as we continue to seek You that You may guide us in all things, give us hearts that yearn for what You yearn for and break for what breaks Yours. Draw us near to you that we may be ever more conformed in the light of You. In Jesus’ mighty name,
Amen.
i Lewis, C, and Walter Hooper. n.d. “GOD in the DOCK ESSAYS
on THEOLOGY and ETHICS.” https://www.OrcuttChristian.
org/Lewis%20CS%20-%20God_in_the_Dock.pdf.
ii Tucker Carlson. (2025, June 18). Tucker Confronts Ted Cruz
on His Support for Regime Change in Iran. YouTube. https://
www.YouTube.com/Watch?v=smemFVe0l5E
iii Lohnes, K. (2019). Siege of Jerusalem | Facts & Summary. In Encyclopædia
Britannica. https://www.Britannica.com/Event/Siege-of-Jerusalem-70
iv Vlach, M. J. (n.d.). Dispensational Theology. The Gospel Coalition. https://
www.TheGospelCoalition.org/Essay/Dispensational-Theology
v Nachtigal, Y. (2016, April 11). The History of Dispensationalism. Christian Observer. https://
ChristianObserver.net/The-History-of-Dispensationalism
vi Stevens, J. (2025, March 1). Tradition and Scripture [Review
of Tradition and Scripture]. Valley Ag Voice. https://www.
ValleyAgVoice.com/Tradition-and-Scripture









