By Natalie Willis, Reporter, Valley Ag Voice
A new report, the Comprehensive Pest Prevention Program Analysis (C3PA) project, found that the state’s Pest Prevention System is facing increasing strain as the number of invasive pests continues to grow. From eradication projects to staffing issues, the report explained that California’s PPS was stretched to capacity in recent crises.
The project is a partnership between the California Department of Food and Agriculture and the California Agricultural Commissioners and Sealers Association. The research team includes experts from the University of California, California State University, CDFA, and several other academic and state partners. This is the first comprehensive evaluation of the system since 1996.
In 2023-2024, California declared seven separate quarantines for invasive fruit flies — the most ever in a single year. Eradication efforts costs amounted to approximately $208 million dollars, with expenses shared equally between the federal and state government, the report explained.
“The best investment we can make in our invasive pest system is to prevent infestations from happening in the first place,” CDFA Secretary Karen Ross said in a press release. “We have a robust and comprehensive approach to detect and eradicate infestations when they do make it into our state and into our fields, but it’s important to limit the need for these more costly measures by keeping pests out when we can, whether that means maintaining rigorous inspection systems, involving the public and stakeholders through outreach, or finding and shutting down new pathways that give these pests a way in.”
The C3PA analysis found that the cost-effectiveness of pest prevention is high but is constrained by underfunding. The report identified over $90 million in one-time funding needs and over $25 million in yearly allocations to improve infrastructure, staffing, pest exclusion, and other programs.
Among the report’s conclusions, it stated that established invasive pests in the 20 crops with the highest farmgate value have cost consumers and producers a combined $563 million per year in lost economic surplus.
The project spotlighted the importance of pest-exclusion programs, including the California Detector Dog teams, the Agricultural Inspection Stations (BPS), and the High-Risk Pest Exclusion program which inspect parcels, nursery shipments, air cargo, private vehicle traffic, and other pathways that can introduce agricultural materials or pests to California.
“Nearly the entire Dog Teams budget, over one-third of the High-Risk Pest Exclusion budget, and the entire BPS budget was justified just by their respective fruit fly detection and exclusion work alone,” the report stated. “This is particularly notable because invasive fruit flies were only 2.7% of all A-rated detections by Dog Teams, 0.8% of all A-rated detections by HRPE, and 4.1% of all A-rated detections by BPS.”
Simply stated, 97.3%, 99.2%, and 95.9% of A-rated pest detection by these three programs generated economic gains for the state.
POLICY FRAMEWORK
California’s evolving policy environment was also analyzed, specifically the Sustainable Pest Management Roadmap which was adopted in 2023 as a policy framework to reduce pesticide use.
California has phased out several key pest-control tools, leaving growers with fewer options when new threats emerge.
“The existence of the SPM for California reflects the state’s unique regulatory environment, where regulatory activity for invasive pest species includes significant policy input from the California Environmental Protection Agency (Cal EPA) and the California Department of Pesticide Regulation (CA-DPR),” the C3PA report stated.
In a press release, Lindsey Carter, Executive Director of CACASA, explained that effective pest prevention would reduce reliance on pesticides.
“When invasive pests establish, pesticide use rises,” Carter said. “When eradication is successful, it drops back down. But when eradication fails, elevated pesticide use becomes the new normal.”
The C3PA report identified key areas of investment to modernize sterile insect rearing facilities and expand detector dog teams.
E-COMMERCE THREATS
The report flagged electronic commerce websites as high-level emerging threats, noting that incursions of pest species into California have increased from 1990-2010 and are expected to continue increasing due to rising trade, e-commerce, and passenger travel.
Plants and soil are categories of goods that can be found for purchase on most business-to-consumer and consumer-to-consumer websites. Researchers found that only 16 out of 62 surveyed websites clearly displayed the restrictions for shipping plant material to California.
The researchers analyzed the presence of pests in e-commerce shipments for a small minority of packages tracked in Computerized Delivery Sequence United States Postal Service workbooks, finding that e-commerce-origin packages were more likely to contain at least one pest.
Researchers concluded that most websites outside of the largest platforms fail to properly communicate shipping restrictions, thereby putting agricultural sectors at risk.
The complete 516-page C3PA analysis is available through CDFA’s website.









