(Photo: Dusan Kostic / Adobe Stock)

By Natalie Willis, Reporter, Valley Ag Voice

The State of California’s current constitution, which has been amended over 500 times since its adoption in 1879, requires that all uses of water must be “reasonable and beneficial.” This benign request is not accompanied by an exact definition of what that means in practice, but notes that it does not take away lawful water rights, provided that those rights are used, again, reasonably.

Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary defines reasonable as being in accordance with reason, fairness, duty, or prudence. Cambridge Dictionary defines reasonable as being based on or using good judgment, therefore being fair and practical. Cornell Law School defines reasonable as just, rational, appropriate, ordinary, or usual under the circumstances.

California’s reasonable use doctrine does not offer a concrete definition. According to a 2015 report from Brian E. Gray of the UC Hastings College of Law, reasonable use is described as a flexible, changing standard dependent on current water conditions, competing demands, and evolving social, economic, and environmental needs. Meaning that a water use deemed acceptable at one time may later become unreasonable as circumstances change.

“The doctrine of reasonable use is thus both a policy mandate and a limitation on water rights. A part of California’s Constitution since 1928, it applies to all branches of government, to all levels of governmental administration of the state’s water resources, and to public and private uses of the state’s waters,” Gray stated. “Its overarching directives, comprehensive reach, and infusion into the water rights system make it the most powerful of all of the laws that govern California’s water resources.”

The California State Water Resources Control Board’s definition for beneficial uses commonly includes domestic, municipal, agricultural and industrial supply, power generation, recreation, aesthetic enjoyment, navigation, and preservation and enhancement of fish, wildlife, and other aquatic resources or preserves.

The flexible constitutional standards of reasonable and beneficial use are applied through regulatory decisions by the State Water Board, which determine how water is allocated and managed across competing uses during both normal and drought conditions.

For added context, the State Water Board is the only agency with authority to administer water rights in California and shares the authority to enforce water rights laws with the state courts, according to the SWRCB website.

The State Water Board is led by five board members who set policy and regulate water quality and water rights. Board members are appointed by the governor of California and confirmed by the Senate. The executive director is appointed by the board members and is responsible for the overall leadership and management of the agency.

“The State Water Board has jurisdiction over waste and unreasonable use of water and potential impact to public trust resources of the State, regardless of the type of water right being exercised,” the SWRCB’s website stated.

SEE YOU IN COURT

Over the years, landmark court cases have generally upheld the State Water Board’s authority to define and enforce reasonable and beneficial use, along with the power to modify water rights based on the public trust and reasonable use doctrines.

In 2020, Stanford Vina Ranch Irrigation Company sued the State of California — the State Water Board among the defendants — over the Board’s issuance of temporary emergency regulations in 2014 and 2015 that limited water diversions from Deer Creek and other Sacramento River tributaries to protect Chinook salmon and steelhead trout during migration periods.

Stanford Vina Ranch Irrigation Company challenged the regulations and related curtailment orders that restricted its water use during severe drought conditions. The company argued the Board acted improperly in adopting and enforcing the rules.

Then-California Attorney General Xavier Becerra — current gubernatorial candidate — and his office defended the Board’s authority to issue emergency curtailment orders and restrict water usage during droughts to protect endangered species. The California Court of Appeal ruled that the Board has broad authority to regulate unreasonable water use in California, including setting minimum flow requirements to protect fish species during droughts.

“While we acknowledge Stanford Vina’s previously-adjudicated right to use roughly 66% of the flow of Deer Creek, this right is limited by the rule of reasonableness for the reasons discussed at length above,” the court ruled. “We agree with the trial court’s determination that although ‘[t]he decree is conclusive as to the rights of all existing claimants upon the stream system lawfully embraced in the determination’[…] it does not prevent the Board from adopting regulations and issuing curtailment orders to prevent an unreasonable use of water under Article X, Section 2.”

In 1986, another court ruling in the United States v. State Water Resources Control Board case, often called the “Racanelli Decision,” upheld the Board’s authority to regulate federal and state water projects to protect water quality in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta. The Court of Appeals established that the Board may modify water rights to protect fish, wildlife, and water quality.

The court dispute arose after the Board adopted a water quality plan and a water rights decision requiring the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation and the California Department of Water Resources to either release more water into the Delta or reduce exports to maintain environmental standards.

Reclamation argued the Board lacked authority to modify existing water permits and that the rules impaired vested water rights. The appellate court ruled that the Board acted within its authority under California law and the public trust doctrine and stated that the Board was not required to make formal findings of fact when adopting water quality standards in its legislative role.

“First, the Board’s promulgation of the water quality standards in the Plan was a quasi-legislative action for which findings of fact were not required,” the court ruling stated.

The court further stated that judicial review of board decisions is limited. Courts may determine whether the Board acted within its authority, followed fair procedures, and made reasonable decisions, but they may not substitute their own policy judgments for the agency’s expertise. Board actions must be upheld unless they are arbitrary, capricious, or unsupported by evidence.

Another ruling by the Court of Appeals in 2014 pertaining to water rights was the Light v. State Water Resources Control Board decision, which found that the Board may regulate any water use, including riparian and pre‑1914 appropriations, if the use is unreasonable and harms public trust.

The case stemmed back to April 2008, where vineyard owners and a grower association diverted Russian River water for frost protection. The diversions lowered water levels, leading to the death of young salmon. The SWRCB then adopted a regulation that required water demand management programs and treated noncompliant frost diversions as unreasonable and prohibited.

“We conclude that, in regulating the unreasonable use of water, the Board can weigh the use of water for certain public purposes, notably the protection of wildlife habitat, against the commercial use of water by riparian users and early appropriators,” the court ruling stated. “Further, the Board may exercise its regulatory powers through the enactment of regulations, as well as through the pursuit of judicial and quasi-judicial proceedings.”

Thus, the ruling found that the Board has authority to prioritize public trust purposes, such as environmental protection, over commercial water use. The court explained that water use by both riparian users and appropriators has been constrained by the rule of reasonableness since 1928.

“California courts have never defined, nor as far as we have been able to determine, even attempted to define what constitutes an unreasonable use of water, perhaps because the reasonableness of any particular use depends largely on the circumstances,” the court ruling stated.

WORKIN’ 90-5

One modern application of California’s constitutional water standard is applied in practice through Order 90-5, which established operational requirements for the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation’s management of the Shasta Dam, Keswick Dam, the Spring Creek Power Plant, and the Trinity River Division as it relates to temperature control in the Upper Sacramento River.

Order 90-5 was adopted by the State Water Board in 1990 and focuses on maintaining river temperatures at levels intended to protect fishery resources, enforceable through monitoring and reporting obligations.

“The general welfare of this state requires that water resources be put to beneficial use to the fullest extent of which they are capable, and that the waste or unreasonable use or unreasonable method of use of water be prevented,” the order stated. “The Bureau’s permits are conditioned as a matter of law upon compliance with this section.”

Article X, Section 2 of the California Constitution states that the right to use water is limited to what is reasonably required for a beneficial use to be served, not extending to waste or unreasonable use.

The SWRCB defines a water right as “a legal entitlement authorizing water to be diverted from a specified source and put to beneficial, non-wasteful use. Water rights are property rights, but their holders do not own the water itself. They possess the right to use it.”

This means that water rights are not fixed guarantees. Their exercise remains subject to changing hydrologic conditions, regulatory requirements, and evolving interpretations of what constitutes reasonable and beneficial use under state law.

Order 90-5 illustrates how California’s modern regulatory framework treats river temperature management for fish survival as a beneficial use of water under Article X, Section 2.

On April 29, 2026, the Bureau of Reclamation submitted its draft 2026 Sacramento River Temperature Management Plan as required by Order 90-5. In essence, the plan describes how Reclamation proposes to operate Shasta Reservoir and the Temperature Control Device on Shasta Dam for the 2026 temperature management season.

“The Plan establishes temperature locations and targets through October 31, 2026, and estimates winter-run Chinook salmon egg mortality, dates for operation of the side gates on the TCD, and end of September cold water pool in Shasta reservoir,” Reclamation’s draft plan stated. “Reclamation will monitor the cold water pool, compare measured conditions to actual performance during implementation, and provide regular updates through the [Sacramento River Group] throughout Plan implementation.”

The draft plan mentions agriculture use once in the considerations section, stating that water diversions on the Sacramento River were expected to increase mid-April as agricultural water demands increase.

“As these depletions increase, releases from Shasta would increase to meet demands,” the draft plan stated.

CAN YOU USE IT IN A SENTENCE, PLEASE?

California’s constitutional standard of the reasonable and beneficial use of water is also a foundational legal principle informing the implementation of the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act.

As documented in the State Water Resources Control Board’s January 2026 publication of California statutes and regulations pertaining to groundwater management, the legislative intent of SGMA is to enhance local management of groundwater consistent with Article X, Section 2 of the California Constitution.

“The people of the state have a primary interest in the protection, management, and reasonable beneficial use of the water resources of the state, both surface and underground, and that the integrated management of the state’s water resources is essential to meeting its water management goals,” the SWRCB’s public information booklet stated.

SGMA reflects a shift in California groundwater policy where the constitutional requirement of reasonable and beneficial use is operationalized through statutory sustainability criteria that translate a legal standard into measurable management targets and sustainability thresholds. It evaluates groundwater level impacts through “significant and unreasonable” terminology.

On May 6, 2026, a research study published in the Environmental Policy and Governance journal examined how agricultural producers in the Tulare Lake Basin understand and perceive climate risk, groundwater governance, and adaptation under SGMA.

Researchers from the University of California, Davis and the University of Rochester found that the majority of producers viewed SGMA policy uncertainty and governance processes as more immediate operational risks over water scarcity, drought, or biophysical risks.

According to the study, “When Policy Is the Hazard: Institutional Legitimacy and Climate Risk Attribution Among Farmers in Water Stressed California,” a majority of the 195 growers that were surveyed view SGMA as a constraint on viability rather than a regulatory framework to establish long-term groundwater sustainability.

“Yet farmers across our sample also expressed willingness to participate in drought mitigation when policies were perceived as procedurally fair, locally grounded, and economically viable,” the study found. “This suggests flexible, incentive-based approaches may be considerably more effective in rural agricultural contexts than compliance-driven mandates.”

The study further documents that growers’ concerns about SGMA are associated with perceptions of inflexibility, allocation uncertainty, and regulatory burden.

“We have sufficient water to support sustainable practices. It’s just a matter of finding the right approach. It’s changes in government policy on water rights that are probably going to have a greater impact on drought and water availability,” a survey participant stated. “Farmers always adapt to changing water levels and we innovate – like we did with root-level irrigation. But what we really need is the chance to innovate and adapt through incentives, not more regulation.”

For many agricultural users, groundwater conditions are no longer experienced solely as a function of hydrology, but as the combined outcome of physical water availability and evolving governance rules that define how that water may be used — in reasonable, beneficial ways, of course.

Previous articlePresident’s Message
Next articleExecutive Director’s Report