By Natalie Willis, Reporter, Valley Ag Voice
“I know now why confusion in government is not only tolerated but encouraged. I have learned. A confused people can make no clear demands.” — John Steinbeck, The Short Reign of Pippin IV
In accordance with the California Budget Act of 2022 — AB 179 — the California Agricultural Land Equity Task Force was established and assigned to submit a report to the Legislature and Governor Newsom by January 1, 2026, on policy recommendations to address the “agricultural land equity crisis.”
Based on the Task Force’s November 2025 draft report, the 13-member group, administered1 by the California Strategic Growth Council, outlined six main recommendations: support tribal stewardship and land return; fund and encourage land purchases for certain producers and land stewards; stop and reverse farmland consolidation; protect farmland while improving equitable access; prioritize secure land ownership; and promote urban agriculture.
The California Budget Act of 2022 was led by former Democratic Assemblymember and Budget Chair Phil Ting. The Act was part of California’s record-breaking budget surplus and directed funding to climate initiatives, drought and wildfire response, housing programs, and other identified priorities such as expanded park access and support for higher education.
It also provided $1 million to fund the creation of the Task Force. During his time in the Assembly, Ting’s top financial supporters included labor unions, healthcare interests, real estate groups, tribal governments, and lawyers and lobbyists, according to OpenSecrets.
The Task Force defines agricultural land equity as follows: “Agricultural land equity is when all people have secure and affordable access to viable land for the care, relationship with, and cultivation of food, fiber, medicine, and cultural resources without systemic barriers, disparities, or exploitation.”
In order to advance this, the stated goal is to change policies, practices, systems, and structures to counter concentrated market forces and ownership of natural resources. The recommendations in the report have been in development from October 2023 to December 2025, and members have participated in various public meetings throughout California.
Along with establishing loan forgiveness programs for “priority producers” — socially disadvantaged farmers and ranchers — the Task Force recommends that California provide state-owned lands to Native American Tribes.
“Approximately 4% of California’s cropland is owned by local, state, federal, or another form of non-Tribal government, and roughly 50% of this land is fallowed,” the Task Force’s draft report states. “This publicly held land – and in particular parcels that are agriculturally viable with secure, sufficient water – presents a significant land access opportunity for priority producers and land stewards.”
Moreover, the Task Force is recommending the voluntary return of privately held land to Native American Tribes.
The existing legal framework the Task Force utilizes includes the 2017 Farmer Equity Act, AB 1348, and the Agriculture Improvement Act of 2018, H.R. 2. These offer definitions for socially disadvantaged farmers pertaining to race, ethnicity, gender, as well as beginning farmers and veterans.
As an advisory body, the Task Force is not equipped with the power to craft and implement legislation. Rather, it was established to produce a report with recommendations – any legislative action taken would be under the direction of the California Legislature and Governor.
THE NITTY
It should be explicitly stated that California and its political actors are not forcing the redistribution of private land — that would create a lot of issues from a public relations standpoint.
Instead, regulatory costs and pressures have gradually made California agriculture less viable, according to a 2024 Cal Poly study, “Two Decades of Change: Evolving Costs of Regulatory Compliance in the Produce Industry.” Over time, that pressure may shift land from private producers to conservation or public ownership, redistributing land use and control through policy rather than force.
For example, in January 2025, the National Park Service announced a settlement wherein 12 of 14 ranching operations in Point Reyes National Seashore agreed to end their leases and vacate the land within 15 months in exchange for compensation from The Nature Conservancy.
The settlement stems from a 2022 lawsuit filed by the Center for Biological Diversity, Western Watersheds Project, and Resource Renewal Institute against the National Park Service, challenging its management plan that renewed long-term grazing leases at Point Reyes.
“This is an exciting moment for Point Reyes National Seashore. Thanks to agreements between TNC and the closing ranch operations, the park’s future management will include additional opportunities for visitors, non-lethal management of native tule elk, and honors the co-stewardship agreement with the Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria,” Point Reyes National Seashore Superintendent Anne Altman said in a press release.
Kevin Lunny, a third-generation rancher, told KQED that the relationship between the park service and ranchers had been deteriorating over the past two decades.
“Even though I knew it was coming, it’s super hard,” Lunny told KQED. “Even though deep down we believe it’s the right thing, and we did it voluntarily … we felt so much in a corner that we didn’t know what else to do.”
Under the revised management plan, the National Park Service will rezone about 16,000 acres of former agricultural land into a Scenic Landscape zone focused on resource conservation. The plan also allows tule elk to roam throughout the National Seashore and increase without a population cap.
Such gradual shifts in land and resource control are emerging across California through regulatory and legal channels.
In August 2025, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission approved Pacific Gas & Electric’s flow‑variance request for the Potter Valley Project. PG&E plans to remove two dams on the Eel River — Scott Dam and Cape Horn Dam — as part of its project, with the removal process anticipated to begin in 2028.
This reduces diversions of water from the Eel River into the Russian River basin which supports irrigated agriculture.
By declining to renew its federal license for the Potter Valley Project, PG&E set in motion the formal decommissioning of Scott and Cape Horn Dams, motivated primarily by cost and safety concerns. FERC holds final authority over the surrender process and the project’s timeline.
According to the Eel-Russian Project Authority, a lack of diversion will result in greatly diminished water supplies for the Russian River Watershed “affecting agriculture, fire suppression, ecosystems, recreation and drinking water supply, and pose a serious risk of Lake Mendocino draining in drought years.”
The costs associated with decommissioning and removing the dams are passed on to ratepayers subject to approval of the California Public Utilities Commission.
According to a 2023 Sonoma County Farm Bureau report, “Economic Impact of Potter Valley Project (PVP) and Estimated Effects on Sonoma County,” the removal of Potter Valley Project dams will likely result in the loss of agricultural and commercial output and incomes.
“Agriculture in Sonoma County (as well as Mendocino County) is the prime water-using industry (approximately 65.8 percent of use),” the report stated. “The shock of water reductions fall on farmers more than other businesses, though light and heavy manufacturing that is water-based feels these effects as well.”
The Potter Valley Irrigation District provides irrigation water for 390 farmers irrigating within the PVID boundary of 6,900 acres of land. According to PVID’s website, the agricultural economy of Potter Valley has grown with the presence of the water diverted through the Potter Valley Project.
The removal of these dams would increase water uncertainty and threaten the long-term viability of agriculture in the region.
THE GRITTY
More broadly, California has been steadily moving toward its goal of conserving 30% of land and coastal water by 2030 — aptly named 30×30. The initiative was spearheaded by Governor Newsom’s Executive Order N-82-20 in 2020.
As of June 2025, 26.1% of lands and 21.9% of coastal waters are under long-term conservation, with 853,000 acres of land and 191,000 acres of coastal waters conserved this year. It also detailed the permanent conservation of over 10,000 acres of working rangeland on Waltz-Turner Ranch, a multi-generational cattle operation in Merced and Mariposa counties.
California’s 30×30 initiative is supported by a variety of programs, including the Tribal Nature-Based Solutions Program which was established by the California Natural Resources Agency to fund tribal land reacquisition.
According to CNRA, the program was created during tribal consultations on Newsom’s Executive Order, the Pathways to 30×30 Strategy, and Natural and Working Lands Climate Smart Strategy.
On October 29, Newsom announced the distribution of 17,030 acres of land to the Tule River Indian Tribe, stating that it advances the goals of 30×30. The land includes the 14,673-acre Hershey Ranch and the 2,357-acre Carothers Ranch.
“This is the largest ancestral land return in the Sierra Nevada foothills and Central Valley region, and a milestone in California’s efforts to address historical wrongs against California Native American tribes, as well as in the state’s work to restore and protect critical ecosystems,” the press release stated.
The Tribe is partnering with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife to reintroduce tule elk in the area, which has also seen a resurgence of gray wolves.
As an aside, the Yowlumni wolf pack — named in collaboration with the Tule River Tribe and whose home range lies primarily on tribal lands — has been linked to several livestock depredations according to California Department of Fish and Wildlife investigations.
PRICE OF CONFUSION
The California Agricultural Land Equity Task Force’s deadline to submit its report to the Legislature and Governor is approaching on January 1, 2026. Based on initial drafts, expected policy recommendations will focus on redistributing farmland to “priority” producers and Tribal Nations.
Efforts to return land to tribes, expand conservation, and redefine agricultural equity may be well-intentioned, but the practical effect for farmers and ranchers is fewer viable acres, higher uncertainty, and added pressure on family operations already facing water shortages, labor challenges, and rising costs.
From Point Reyes and Potter Valley to lands earmarked for 30×30, it is important to consider how policies, lawsuits, and voluntary agreements can shift control of productive farmland without requiring direct confiscation. While navigating the maze of regulations, policies, and hidden definitions can be overwhelming, in agriculture, confusion comes at a price.
- Clarification: As per the California Governor’s Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation, the Task Force is administered, not overseen, by the Strategic Growth Council. ↩︎









