
By Scott Hamilton, President, Hamilton Resource Economics
It was the 29th of February 2024. The big storm that would drop 10 feet of snow off the Sierra Nevada in early March was yet to arrive. Still, floodwaters made their way through the Yolo Bypass, circumnavigating Sacramento and saving the city from flooding. Despite the floodwater, the State Water Project allocation was at 15% and the state’s share of San Luis Reservoir was less than half full. On that day, the California Department of Water Resources projected the flow from the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta to the Pacific Ocean was 111,600 cfs – a flow just shy of one-quarter of a million acre-feet per day. The State Water Project pumps were operating at 5,000 acre-feet per day – about one-quarter of their capacity.
The water project pumps were limited to help protect endangered fish. The fish of concern that day were steelhead. For some unknown reason, the crop of steelhead in 2024 was enormous. If population estimates were made and recorded it could have been the largest production in 50 years. But no one knows. There is no estimate of the population of out-migrating steelhead. And they were being salvaged at the pumps at numbers previously unseen. But were the projects salvaging 0.1% of the fish or 10%? Were the pumps creating population-level impacts? Again, no one knows. So out of an abundance of caution, pumping was restricted.
If it had not been steelhead limiting pumping, it would have been some other species – most likely delta smelt. Natural delta smelt is now observed very rarely in the Delta. Their numbers are being supported through the supplementation of propagated (hatchery) fish. Over the last few years, nearly 300,000 have been added to Delta waters. Delta smelt is the species most likely to limit exports from January through June – the time when surplus water exists in the Delta. But why? How should the pumps be operated to protect fish?
A National Academy of Sciences Committee met in California for the second time in a month with that question in mind. The problem is tricky. When the State Water Project was initiated in the mid-1960s, the project wasn’t fully built. As California’s population grew, it was envisioned that additional facilities would be added to the Project to provide the yield that the water users had contracted for. At buildout, the yield the state had promised the contractors was 4 million acre-feet. That quantity was the amount that was to be delivered on average through a five-year drought. The yield these days is far from that – close to about 2.5 million acre-feet per year – which is an average over all years, not drought years. The critical piece of the Project not built was the Peripheral Canal, defeated by California voters in 1982. The Peripheral Canal would have provided better quality water to the State and Federal projects, protected the projects from an earthquake or flood failure in the Delta, and with newer technology, protected fish from entrainment. However, there was a fear that the Peripheral Canal would decimate the Delta ecosystem and reduce water quality to in-Delta users. So, the canal was never built.
Most of the water exported comes from the Sacramento River. That water must make its way across the Delta through a system of waterways never intended for the volumes needed. Two primary channels leading to the pumps are the Old River and Middle River. For water management purposes, the flow in these rivers is combined into one metric – Old and Middle rivers flow (“OMR”). The Delta is a tidal system meaning that uni-directional flows in the Delta are rare – most of the time there are massive inflows with the incoming tide and massive outflows with the outgoing tide. For water management purposes, those tidal flows are averaged. When the pumps are working hard and flows on the San Joaquin River are low, the tidally averaged OMR flow is southward, toward the pumps, in the opposite direction of its natural flow. During the risk period for delta smelt, the maximum permitted tidally averaged southward OMR flow is 5,000 cfs with the understanding that this will limit the movement of fish toward the pumps. The state and federal pumps combined can pump three times that quantity. The dilemma is then simply stated – with SGMA requiring maximum recharge of flood water to achieve groundwater sustainability without massive landfallowing and with a competing need to protect endangered fish, how should OMR limits be set? That is the question before the National Academies Committee.
It is, of course, the wrong question. Never mind that with so little natural delta smelt in the estuary, any take at project pumps is easily mitigated with the addition of propagated fish (a strategy not lost on the NAS Committee). The correct question is: how can the projects divert water without harming fish? The last time a NAS Committee engaged in Delta issues was 2010. One of their findings was that: “with the correct water engineering, entrainment effects might be eliminated.”
The United States put a man on the moon more than 50 years ago. It should be possible now to divert water without harming fish. The NAS thinks so. The technology exists. But an additional $600,000 is needed by water contractors for a demonstration project in the Delta to prove that it works in an estuarine system – a sum that has proved elusive. In the meantime, a quarter of a million-acre feet per day of flood water flows to the ocean while Kern’s recharge basins lie empty.








