
By Scott Hamilton, President, Hamilton Resource Economics
The road to meaningful change in managing California’s scarce water resources is long and dusty. The journey is not for those in a hurry. Patience, perseverance, a willingness to listen, a desire to be understood, a solid plan, and friends who believe in the cause – these are essential for success.
Recognizing this, there have been several collaborative efforts formed with the intent of forging a water solution for the Valley. Valley Ag Voice has provided numerous updates on the work of the Water Blueprint for the San Joaquin Valley. That organization seeks to mobilize the Valley into a single voice on water issues to minimize miscommunications between legislators and Valley residents. Well aware of the prospects for the Valley if the only tool in the SGMA toolbox is land “repurposing,” it seeks solutions that will see farms and communities in the Valley continue to thrive. Those solutions are fundamentally water supply-based – capturing more high-flow water and conveying it to long-term storage that can survive the volatile nature of the state’s precipitation.
Recently, the Bureau of Reclamation sought to develop a new unified plan for the Valley and granted $1 million to the California Water Institute, based at Fresno State, and the Water Blueprint to develop that plan over the next two years. While the Bureau engaged in previous planning efforts, these were developed pre-SGMA and were not focused on achieving groundwater sustainability for each basin. The new plan requires accurate identification of future water needs at the local level, assessment of how much additional high-flow water, if any, can be realistically captured and stored, and projections of the conveyance facilities necessary to move the high water from its source to new storage facilities. Consideration of community needs, including water quality and reliability, as well as environmental needs will be featured in the plan. The plan is expected to identify a series of new projects, operating in conjunction with one another. If the plan is acceptable to the Bureau, feasibility studies on the individual projects will commence. A finding of feasibility opens the door to federal funding for the projects.
On a parallel path, the San Joaquin Collaborative Action plan (CAP) also seeks to identify a water solution for the Valley. This effort contains a broader group of constituents with more diverse interests but essentially the same goal. Five caucuses are engaged in the effort: water districts, farmers, communities, local government and environmentalists. If the CAP can agree on a solution, it would carry broader political support which normally translates into increased funding for water projects.
In continuing its effort to move forward, the CAP set year-end goals that fall into four categories: safe drinking water, sustainable water supply, ecosystem health, and land repurposing/demand reduction. The water supply goals mirror the Bureau’s objectives for the Valley in terms of understanding diverse needs and identifying projects to capture high-flow water from Valley rivers and the Delta without adversely impacting the environment.
Are all these disparate planning efforts necessary? Would the efforts be more effective if merged? The dynamics of these groups in funding and their ability to stay the course vary, and therefore their ability to succeed varies. Perhaps it is strategic to bet on more than one horse. Regardless, there are a lot of people trying very hard to understand the water needs of the Valley and to work with others to develop a practical solution.
That, in itself, is encouraging.








