irrigation canal
(Photo: Straight 8 Photography/Shutterstock.)

By Natalie Willis, Reporter, Valley Ag Voice 

A decade after the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act became law, many California farmers still feel lost in the bureaucracy surrounding its implementation. A new study finds that, despite widespread awareness, real engagement remains low. 

According to research from CSU-WATER — an initiative encompassing 23 California State University campuses — significant logistical and representational barriers have prevented farmers from meaningfully engaging with their Groundwater Sustainability Agencies.  

The research is part of SGMA WAVE — short for Water and Valley Economy — a project led by CSU-WATER, a water policy initiative involving all 23 CSU campuses. The study focuses on 72 GSAs across the San Joaquin Valley counties of Madera, Fresno, Tulare, Kings, and Kern.   

The study was led by Dr. Steve Blumenshine of CSU-Water and Dr. Anita Chaudhry of CSU-Chico — input was also received from Dr. Dean Fairbanks of CSU-Chico.  

Through a survey of 279 farmers within the five aforementioned counties, it was revealed that while awareness of SGMA is high at 92%, only about a third of farmers have participated in SGMA-related events. This lack of participation was largely attributed to logistical barriers, representation concerns, growing mistrust, and economic divides. 

AWARE BUT NOT ENGAGED 

The CSU study focused on five dimensions of SGMA engagement — awareness, participation, trust in representation, perceived impacts, and access to information.  

According to the survey, 25% of respondents did not participate in SGMA-related events due to a lack of timely communication. Another 16% cited that meeting times and locations were inconvenient, and 15% felt that some groups of farmers are not adequately represented within the GSA.  

When asked to rate how their interests were being represented by GSAs, responses were split fairly evenly across the board — roughly one-third said “poorly,” roughly one-third were neutral, and roughly one-third felt positively represented.  

During a webinar on the study’s findings, Chaudhry shared comments from some of the farmers and farm managers.  

“So, here’s a sample just to kind of give you a sense of what farmers are saying: ‘Small farmers lose out, large landowners have the power on the board, they can afford to leave some ground fallow and sell their water rights and recharge. We have clay soil, so we are to recharge. That leaves us with little water and dry years with new pumping restrictions,’” Chaudhry shared. 

Another farmer said, “SGMA is aimed at putting farmers like me out of business. They do not have my best interest at heart.” 

According to Chaudhry, the survey responses indicate a large trust deficit and large power differences in subsets of the farming community. For instance, farms under 180 acres and those outside of irrigation districts were significantly less likely to participate in SGMA meetings, as well as farmers who worked outside of agriculture. 

Since it was signed into law in 2014, SGMA has been treated largely as an engineering and hydrology challenge, but little attention was paid to its social or economic impacts.  

“You have a commonly shared resource. Now, we have to figure out where the boundaries are and how we’re going to manage it sustainably,” Chaudhry said. “It’s a classic social science problem.” 

At the California State Senate’s Natural Resources and Water Committee informational hearing on SGMA held on March 11, Paul Gosselin, deputy director for Sustainable Water Management at DWR, noted that the most challenging phase of SGMA implementation is only now beginning.  

“The next five years, just looking ahead, are going to be somewhat rocky. I’ve been saying the easy part’s over. You know, the planning part’s over,” Gosselin said. “The first couple of years were GSA formations getting ducks lined up, getting plans done. And so really, plans just started getting implemented five years ago, but now the rubber is meeting the road.” 

Thus, as implementation ramps up and the real-world impacts of groundwater sustainability efforts begin to surface, the challenges are no longer theoretical — they’re tangible and, in many cases, contentious.  

While early stages focused on building frameworks and securing local agency cooperation, the focus has now shifted to difficult decisions about who will bear the largest burden of SGMA’s impacts.  

“I think you are looking at a very wicked problem, as we say in social science…I mean, of course, when you have a resource that’s getting depleted and you want to achieve sustainability, it’s like musical chairs — when some chairs get pulled out, some players are out,” Chaudhry said. “So, the political question is, ‘Who gets to be pulled out?’ I mean, if you’re going to reduce the use, of course, somebody is not going to be able to grow the crop. Some land is going to go idle. I don’t think there is two ways about it.” 

ECONOMIC STAKES 

Growers are not only frustrated with their lack of representation on GSA boards — they are also concerned about the economic future of their farms under SGMA. In the survey, 70% of respondents believed that SGMA would hinder long-term financial performance, and 61% expect land values to decline. 

“But overall, there’s a pretty pessimistic perception about what SGMA is going to do to your farm’s market value, financial performance, and irrigation supplies,” Chaudhry explained in the webinar.  

These fears are amplified by broader land-use trends where agricultural land use is being steadily chipped away. Still, while agricultural land use may shrink, some growers could still benefit — those who remain in farming may see higher prices due to reduced supply.  

“SGMA is about creating, to put it bluntly, winners and losers. People who get to stay in agriculture will get to enjoy a sustainable groundwater supply,” Chaudhry said. 

NEXT PHASE 

Armed with these initial findings, the CSU team is working toward Phase Two of the project, focused on groundwater demand reduction. According to Blumenshine, they are invited external input to continue informing the second phase of research.  

For more information, contact Dr. Steve Blumenshine at sblumens@mail.fresnostate.edu. 

Previous articleSGMA Implementation Accelerates Farmland Value Declines 
Next articleValley Ag Voice Reporter Wins Award for Agricultural Journalism