By Natalie Willis, Reporter, Valley Ag Voice
As California farmers continue to face high regulatory and compliance costs driven by stricter food safety, labor, and environmental rules, imported products produced under less stringent standards threaten to undercut domestic competitiveness.
According to a Cal Poly case study published earlier this year, regulatory costs for a commercial-scale lettuce grower in the Salinas Valley increased by 1,366% from 2006 to 2024.
“Regulatory costs comprised just 1.24% of production costs in 2006, then rose to 8.9% of production costs in 2017, and are now calculated at 12.6% of production costs,” the study stated.
For added context, the lettuce grower referenced in the study saw regulatory costs per acre rise from $109 in 2006 to $1,600 by the end of 2024. As these costs have continued to rise, farm-gate prices for lettuce remain relatively flat.
According to the study, “Two Decades of Change: Evolving Costs of Regulatory Compliance in the Produce Industry” — authored by professors of agribusiness at Cal Poly Lynn Hamilton and Michael McCullough — the combined costs of food safety compliance were $244.15 per acre. This represents a 35% increase from 2017, and thousands of percent higher than the 2006 food safety cost of $0.64 per acre.
Meanwhile, foreign importers and their suppliers are not held to the exact food safety standards as California growers. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration utilizes a Foreign Supplier Verification Programs rule, requiring importers to verify that foreign suppliers meet U.S. safety standards, but it does not address the overall cost of production.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s 2024 production expense ranking shows that the cost to grow in California is the highest in the country, accounting for roughly $48 million and 10.5% of total production expenses in the U.S. California also accounts for the highest total U.S. labor, pesticide, fuel, and electricity expenses.
Added to that, California Citrus Quality Council President Jim Cranney explained that the state’s citrus industry is facing increased competition from lower-priced imports to the U.S., The Packer reported.
“Recently, we’ve seen more difficulties on the export side and a lot of imports coming into the U.S., so much so that, regrettably, I would say when we look at trade policy, we’re paying a lot of attention on the import side,” Cranney said.
Since the USDA’s Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service granted market access for Argentina lemons in 2016, their lower-priced commodities have created strong competition for California growers.
A 2018 study commissioned by the California Citrus Research Board found that new regulations would cost the state’s citrus growers an average of $203 million annually, as increasing labor mandates, environmental rules, and water limitations collectively strain farmers’ ability to sustain their operations.
Additionally, California farmers have seen compliance costs increase 12 to 14 times higher than in years past, according to an AgNet West discussion with Daniel Hartwig, president of the California Fresh Fruit Association.
In contrast, Cranney explained, there is a large differential in California’s cost of production compared to Argentina.
“The Environmental Protection Agency’s Endangered Species Act? You can multiply that by 10 with requirements that are necessary in the state of California,” Cranney told The Packer. “The regulatory costs for producers here are tremendous, so we feel the playing field is unfair for California citrus producers.”
CONSUMER CONUNDRUM
Food safety is an important consideration for U.S. consumers — at least, they think it is. According to new research from the International Food Information Council, which has surveyed American consumers for 20 years, confidence in the safety of the U.S. food supply has declined rapidly.
The survey, conducted in March 2025, focused on food and ingredient safety with a sample of 3,000 Americans from ages 18 to 30 years. Of the findings, confidence in the domestic food supply has fallen while confidence in the safety of imported foods has increased.
“Perception of the safety of imported foods is more positive now than it was a decade ago…Three in 10 (30%) think imported foods are as safe as foods produced or grown in the U.S., up 6 points from 2014,” IFIC reported. “One in 10 (12%) think that imported foods are safer than foods produced or grown in the U.S., a 9- point increase from 2014.”
Additionally, the number of Americans who are very or somewhat confident in the safety of the U.S. food supply in 2025 reached 55%, the lowest recorded point in the 13-years IFIC has measured attitudes on food supply safety.
Those lacking confidence in U.S. food safety cited various reasons such as the perception that profit is prioritized over safety, the belief that not all stakeholders in the food system are cooperating to ensure safety, doubts about the strictness of government safety regulations, and concerns over the frequency of product recalls.
Americans identified foodborne illness as the top food safety issue overall at 50%, followed by carcinogens at 47%, and pesticides and pesticide residues at 46%.
Moving down the list systematically, more foodborne illnesses from produce outbreaks are being linked to imported foods, according to a 2017 study by the National Institute of Health. Sixty-four percent of produce-related outbreaks involved products from Latin America and the Caribbean. Nearly all dairy-related outbreaks involved products imported from that same region, NIH reported. Salmonella is the most common pathogen, often found in fruits, seeded vegetables, and sprouts.
More recently, in 2024, a multi-state Salmonella Typhimurium outbreak was linked to cucumbers imported from Mexico. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention concluded its investigation in January 2025, after 113 people in 23 states were infected.
As for carcinogens and pesticide residues, the California Department of Pesticide Regulation’s annual produce monitoring report, released in July 2025, found that about 97% of fruits and vegetables sold in California had either no detectable pesticide residues or had residues below federal health-protective limits.
DPR’s results were based on 3,544 produce samples collected in 2023 from over 500 locations throughout California. These samples, which were unpeeled and unwashed, underwent testing for 500 types of pesticides and related compounds.
Produce samples labeled as “grown in California” had fewer than 1% in detectable residues or those above EPA tolerances, and 3% of samples had illegal residues. However, of the 96 samples with illegal pesticide detection, 83% were linked to imported produce.
Of the imported samples with illegal residues, Ecuador had the highest percentage of violations, followed by Guatemala, China, and Mexico. Produce with the highest percentages of violations included yard-long beans, cactus pear, guava, dragon fruit, chayote, cilantro, and pineapple.
Thus, while California sets the global standard for food safety, quality, and oversight, rising regulatory costs and shifting consumer perceptions will continue to act as obstacles for growers. Increased efforts to educate consumers about the strength of California’s food safety system could help close the gap between perception and reality.









