By Natalie Willis, Reporter, Valley Ag Voice
Amidst the dissonant voices debating the future of California’s dairy industry, one narrative remains steadfast in its determination to rewrite the script. Against a backdrop of skepticism and opposition from environmentalist groups, the story of dairy digesters emerges as a cost-effective solution to meet California’s climate goals — reducing greenhouse gas emissions by roughly 2 million metric tons per year, according to a written statement from the California Air Resources Board.
A study released by the Center for Food Safety claimed that the cost of digesters has not been accurately reported by state regulators. Co-authored by Kevin Fingerman, associate professor of environmental science and management at Cal Poly Humboldt, and environmental scientist Donovan Wakeman, the study utilizes the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund estimates which do not include incentives provided to the dairy industry.
“The Dairy Digester Research and Development Program (DDRDP) administered by the California Department of Food and Agriculture is the second most cost-effective program funded by cap-and-trade proceeds with [an] expenditure of $9 for every ton of CO2 abated,” the study said. “While this figure accurately reflects the expenditures of the DDRDP program, it misrepresents the true cost of these investments by ignoring other sources of funding that have flowed to dairy digester projects in California.”
The study then estimates that the true cost of dairy digesters is $159 per ton with all public funding and market incentives considered. However, according to an emailed response from David Clegern, public information officer for CARB, the purpose of the GGRF Quantification Methodologies is not intended to determine the cost-effectiveness of any project when considering all funding and necessary costs.
Still, $159 per ton is cost-effective amongst state programs, Michael Boccardo, president of West Coast Advisors and executive director of Dairy Cares, noted. To get to this estimate, the study utilizes a five-year average credit price of $160, but footnotes state on page 11 that the current Low Carbon Fuel Standard credit price is “$73 per ton and has been on a decline since 2021.”
“That’s [almost] $90 above where it’s at today, so to get to that $2.8 billion number, he used a five-year average,” Boccardo said.
Altering the equation to fit a five-year average credit price took the state’s estimate of $195 million in total to $589 million for the digester projects. While the Center for Food Safety study clarifies that the estimate is necessarily imprecise, it claims it to be conservative.
“Part of me laughs at that because it still makes it one of the most cost-effective programs in the state,” Boccardo said. “You add all that and you treat it differently than every other project that you’re analyzing, and it still outperforms them.”
While the study explores the incentives for the dairy digester program, it does not apply the same scrutiny to other state programs such as most electric vehicle projects which all have some investment tax credit available to them, referenced in the California Climate Investments 2023 report.
The study concludes with a direct citation of the California Climate Investments report’s 77 listed projects — found in Appendix A — stating that 51 of these projects provide a return-on-investment calculation. Taken as is, the study affirms that the digester program is the second-most cost-effective program, but with its new calculation to include public funding, digesters move to the 22nd most cost-effective.
The study does not clarify if additional calculations were made for the other 50 projects to reach this conclusion.
“[Fingerman’s] critical of the state program for not doing a complete analysis, but then he only does the complete analysis for one type of program and tries to compare it back to the others where he didn’t bother to do the same analysis,” Boccardo said. “So now you’ve got a complete apples-to-oranges type of characterization.”
Further, Steve Lyle, public affairs director for CDFA explained that the ROI calculations are based on the total 141 LCFS-approved dairy pathways, but only 57 directly belong to the state’s DDRDP program.
PAY THE MILKMAN
Another point of contention in the study is that the costs of the LCFS program come from purchasers of transportation fuels which is a form of subsidy from a public cost. However, according to Lyle, it is not unusual for pollution sources to bear the cost of mitigating their pollution, especially considering the benefits the public receives from LCFS.
“The LCFS has replaced billions of gallons of gasoline and diesel fuel with biofuels and other alternatives,” Lyle said in an email. “For example, the program is directly responsible for the major build-out of Electric Vehicle (EV) charging and hydrogen fuel dispensers for fuel cell vehicles, as well as the significant deployment of biofuels in the medium and heavy-duty sector that reduce criteria pollutant emissions compared to diesel use.”
Several programs are funded by California Climate Initiatives. One of the costliest is the Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities program.
The Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities Program received $3,276 million from the GGRF fund, resulting in a reduction of 3,210,080 metric tons of carbon. AHSC was developed to make it easier for Californians to drive less by ensuring housing, jobs, and other destinations are accessible through walking, biking, and transit.
In 2022, 1,353 housing units were built with a claimed reduction of 414,168 metric tons.
An article from Palo Alto online noted that it nets over 300 tons of emission saved per unit — a typical multi-family gas-heated home generates 2 metric tons per year in heating emissions.
“Transportation might generate another 4 MT. How do you get 300 MT in savings for a single unit?” The article states. “Are we assuming that electricity has no emissions, that new residents never drive, and that without this program residents would be driving gas cars and using gas heat for 50 years?”
In comparison, the Dairy Digester Research and Development Program received a collective $309.1 million to this program along with the Alternative Manure Management Program. Out of 125 digesters, approximately 22,101.263 metric tons of CO2 were reduced.
“California’s dairy digester program at this time is the only verified means of limiting methane emissions from CAFOs. Data shows they are reducing those emissions,” Clegern said. “California Climate Investments has funded 125 operational digesters worth $205.4 million through the California Department of Food & Agriculture’s Dairy Digester Research and Development Program (DDRDP) program and the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund (GGRF) per-ton cost of emissions reductions is approximately $9.”
DAIRY FEEDS THE ECONOMY
While dairy and livestock account for most of California’s methane emissions, the dairy industry is also the most effective at reducing its carbon footprint by maintaining sustainable practices and remains one of the largest economic drivers for the state.
According to the California Department of Food and Agriculture, the top-valued commodity in 2022 was dairy products. The industry brings roughly 175,000 jobs — most of which are in the San Joaquin Valley — Boccardo explained. Additionally, 5,470 full-time jobs are supplied by dairy digester projects, Lyle said.
Out of the entirety of California, which holds nine of the 10 top-producing agriculture counties, $10.4 billion of the value comes from dairy.
Even with the consolidation of the agricultural industry overall — including a 50% reduction in dairy farms with fewer than 500 cows, according to the 2022 U.S. Census on Agriculture — the state has continued to meet the demand for more dairy products.
“We’re seeing consolidation in ag, and we know that it’s not necessarily a bad thing because we know with efficiency, producing more crop or more milk with fewer cows or fewer acres provides tremendous environmental benefits to the country and to the state,” Boccardo said. “So, efficiency provides benefits across the board and efficiency comes with economy of scale.
Lyle noted that if California dairies are forced to discontinue operations, they may relocate to other states that do not place the same level of importance on environmental sustainability.
“This could result in heightened methane emissions in these regions, in addition to other environmental issues, thereby exacerbating climate change for the general population,” Lyle said.
Still, environmental justice groups see dairies as environmental hazards that pollute water and “rely on the exploitation of female cows” to meet demand, according to Sentient Media — a publication that reports on the effect of factory farms on climate, animals, health, and politics.
The primary issue for environmentalist groups, Boccardo explained, is that dairy digester programs are effective, but the goal is to get rid of dairies completely. Organizations such as the World Wildlife Fund and The Nature Conservancy have supported the developments in dairy digester projects, showing that the industry can be environmentally sustainable.
“The [Environmental Justice] community is you know, they see digesters as perpetuating dairies in California, which they would like to see leave the state. So that’s the underlying reason for their opposition,” Boccardo said. “It’s not because these projects are not improving environmental performance — they are.”
For now, dairy digesters will continue to work toward California’s GHG reduction goals, amidst the discordant voices of opposition.









