By Scott Hamilton, President, Hamilton Resource Economics 

Delta science issues are complex and controversial, stakeholders are passionate, and disadvantaged communities and farmers — too busy with their daily lives to weigh in — have been caught in the firefight.  The longest running issue is determining what actions might benefit endangered fish.  This is surprising because salmon and smelt have been the subject of recovery efforts for three decades, but their numbers continue to decline. While the scientific knowledge base continues to grow, the progress toward recovering native fish species has not met expectations.   

The target for the latest controversy is “Action 5.”  Action 5 is an effort by the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation (the Bureau) to export more water from the Delta to help ease the pain farmers are suffering as a result of the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act. It looks to modify a number of Delta regulations that the Bureau believes are not well supported by science.   

Valley Ag Voice reported on the proposed Action 5 initiative in a July 11, 2025, article when Adam Nickels spoke at a Water Association of Kern County meeting. At that time, Nickel said the regulations that are limiting pumping are not helping the fish. For background, the State Water Resources Control Board sets water quality and flow standards in its Bay-Delta Plan which is updated periodically.  The State Water Project also has to comply with a mountain of other regulations — the California Endangered Species Act overseen by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife which that has discretionary approval over water operations to protect wildlife, the Federal Endangered Species Act overseen by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and by the National Marine Fisheries, and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers that have oversight over navigable waterways and operations of federal reservoirs. The State Water Project is also subject to decisions by the Delta Water Master and the California Fish and Game Commission. The USBR has similar challenges in operating the Central Valley Project but believes the state regulatory agencies have limited authority over federal water project operations.  The problem with that approach, is noted by Jeff Mount of the Public Policy Institute of California, who stated that “if the federal government decides to not do as much, the state has to make up the difference.” That is, SWP exports may get cut to make up for the extra exports from the CVP.  

Recognizing the need for additional water in the Valley and the weak science supporting actions to protect fish, President Donald Trump signed  Executive Order 14181 on January 31, 2025, to override regulations that unduly burden efforts to maximize water deliveries.  The Executive Order referred to California’s environmental policies as “disastrous.” In response, on December 4, 2025, the Bureau issued a new “Record of Decision” replacing the previous long-term operations decision signed in December 2024. The updated plan works within the flexibility provided in the 2024 Plan.  The Bureau estimated that Action 5 would improve supplies for the CVP, increasing it by 130-to-180-thousand-acre feet per year and SWP supplies by 120-to-220-thousand-acre feet per year. Of particular note, Action 5 is also consistent with the direction in Governor Gavin Newsom’s Executive Order N-16-25, also signed on January 31, 2025, directing state agencies to maximize water supplies. Did this foster cooperation between state and federal government on water management in California? No. Confrontation, rather than collaboration, ensued. 

Action 5 has a few key elements. It removes an action intended to help Delta smelt that required increased flows to the ocean — flows that could have supplemented water supplies to the San Joaquin Valley. In a process administered by an independent facilitator, key scientists from USFWS, along with other scientists, produced studies showing no benefit for the Delta smelt from a flow action. In fact, going back as far as 1995, studies by some of the most renowned Delta scientists have shown no population response to Delta smelt from through-Delta flows. There have been a handful of studies that allege support for additional flows for Delta smelt, but a rigorous review of those studies reveals significant statistical failings.  And then there is the elephant in the room — why are continued protections needed for Delta smelt if they are functionally extinct in the wild and impacts can be mitigated with hatchery fish? 

Another element of Action 5 is a revision to regulations regarding flows in the channels leading toward the pumps, referred to as the Old and Middle River requirement, or OMR, for short. OMR restrictions have a sizable negative impact on water supplies. The restriction is designed to protect fish from losses due to pumping from December through June — the same time the Delta can experience periodic high flows. The fish losses can result from physical losses at the pumps or increased predation before the fish reach the pumps. The water projects have fish screens to divert fish before they reach the pumps. The salvaged fish are returned to the Delta. Nevertheless, a small percentage of fish die in the process.   

The Bureau is proposing a more flexible, risk-based method for managing OMR. During storm events, if there is a low risk assessment, pumping can increase.  If fish are close to the pumps in numbers, pumping will be restricted, but only for as long as there is a risk, not for seven months of the year. Research indicates a more logical risk-based approach is more protective of the fish and allows for increases in water supplies. This research can be found in the study “Identifying the environmental conditions that determine the distribution of an endangered estuarine fish to manage risk of entrainment,” published in Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution. A National Academy of Sciences Committee concluded that population level impacts should be a major factor in determining pumping operations — currently they are not. That’s relevant, because the salvage of a relatively small number of fish should not shut down pumping. In fact, the risk of a population-level impact seems remote for most native fish species.  The Longfin Smelt population is centered in San Pablo Bay some 40 miles to the west of the pumps. The population moves somewhat eastward during low flows, but only a few strays make their way to the pumps, so there is no population level impact.  Losses of Delta smelt can be replaced by hatchery fish, since only hatchery fish remain in Delta waters.  San Joaquin salmon have just as much chance of surviving if they try to make their way down the San Joaquin River, due to intense predation pressure, as they do if they arrive at the pumps. The take of wild Sacramento River salmon is a potential concern. Currently, the risk of take is assessed by salvage of hatchery salmon, but hatchery salmon may not be a good surrogate for wild fish.   

All said, the Action 5 has the potential to increase water supplies while being more protective of native fish. But the State does not agree.  “The Trump administration is putting politics over people — catering to big donors instead of doing what’s right for Californians,” Tara Gallegos, a spokesperson for Governor Newsom’s office told The Sacramento Bee.  The Trump administration says it is putting “people over fish.” The State’s claim is not accurate, and the federal claim is not necessary. Farmers and rural communities are impacted by the State’s unwillingness to consider the science underlying Action 5. Better understanding of the risk factors and opportunities can allow for increased water supplies while being more protective of native fish. 

The fallacy of the state’s position is reflected in a statement by Jeff Mount, when talking to The Sacramento Bee. He explained that because Action 5 would allow more pumping during periods when restrictions are normally in place to protect fish, it would not improve conditions for species that are already in “really bad shape.”  But there is no reason to keep OMR regulations in place when there is no risk to the fish. And there is no reason to let water flow to the ocean when there is no benefit to the fish.   

The current policy has allowed hundreds of thousands of acre feet to flow to the ocean on many days this year — a small portion of which could have been exported without harming fish — as proposed under Action 5.  It is possible to improve water supplies from the Delta and to be more protective of the fish if an informed scientific dialogue can occur and politics can be put aside. 

Previous articleStudents Connect to Agriculture at Farm Day in the City
Next articleUSDA Under Secretary Visits Tulare, Highlights Export Opportunities