By Natalie Willis, Reporter, Valley Ag Voice
Before it was populated by studios and celebrities, Hollywood was a farm. While it may sound like something out of a movie, Bakersfield is just 106 miles from Hollywood, give or take, making the idea a little easier to imagine.
In the mid-1800s, the area now known as Hollywood began as the Cahuenga Valley, a rural agricultural community. The region’s favorable climate made it suitable for growing various crops, including exotic fruits like pineapples, citrus, and avocados.
When Harvey and Daeida Wilcox purchased 160 acres of farmland northwest of Los Angeles in the winter of 1887, the plan was to live a simple life as fig and apricot farmers on their ranch they called Hollywood.
Suffice it to say, Hollywood is not currently an agricultural hub. After his ranching efforts proved unsuccessful, Wilcox began subdividing the land with the intention of creating a utopian-like community for devout Christians.
Suffice it also to say, Hollywood is not currently a hub for Christianity.
Still, the roots of agriculture run deep in the hills of Tinseltown, showing up as a thematic element in films and feeding the men and women who grace the screen. In comparison to the California agriculture industry’s large economic output — almost $60 billion, as estimated by the California Department of Food and Agriculture — Hollywood’s film industry contributes over $30 billion to the economy.
When it comes to subsidies, however, the state prioritizes tax breaks for the film industry. Such is evidenced by Governor Newsom’s efforts to expand investment in film and television tax credits, proposing to expand the credit from $330 million to $750 million.
“California didn’t earn its role as the heart of the entertainment world by accident — it was built over generations by skilled workers and creative talent pushing boundaries,” Newsom said in a press release. “Today’s awards help ensure this legacy continues, keeping cameras rolling here at home, supporting thousands of crew members behind the scenes, and boosting local economies that depend on a strong film and television industry.”
The filmmaking incentives were originally put in place by former Governor — and continuing movie star — Arnold Schwarzenegger in 2009 to combat states and countries offering aggressive financial incentives.
In Hollywood terms, Schwarzenegger told competitors, “Hey, you want to be a farmer? Here’s a couple of acres.”
The expanded tax credit program will result in 48 projects, including 43 independent features, expected to generate $664 million in economic activity and employ over 6,500 cast and crew in California.
However, in the long-term, the benefit to the state’s economy is minimal, according to the nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office.
“Although the film tax credit likely increases the size of California’s film industry, there is weak evidence that expanding the tax credit would benefit California’s economy as a whole,” the Legislative Analyst’s Office stated. “Therefore, we recommend the Legislature consider adopting the Governor’s proposal only if the Legislature views maintaining California’s market share of the film industry as a high priority and an end in itself.”
In a written testimony to the California Senate Revenue and Taxation Committee in March, University of Southern California professor Michael Thom explained that his research on tax incentives for film and television shows that such incentives fail to create jobs or increase wages. In short, they do not stimulate enough economic activity to justify their cost, especially amid a major budget deficit.
“The evidence is consistent and clear that increasing tax incentives for film and television production to three-quarters of a billion dollars annually will only worsen the state’s budget situation,” Thom stated. “Simply put, California cannot afford the existing incentive, much less a substantial expansion to it.”
Additionally, research from the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance explains that tax incentives pick winners and losers. Meaning, when a government entity makes investments in some businesses but not others, there is a concern that those choices may not be justified.
This sentiment is shared by many in the agricultural industry, which ranks higher than the film industry in terms of economic output. According to Corey Lunde, Vice President of External Affairs at Western Growers, while the state is working to entice film and TV production in California, it is not incentivizing farmers to stay.
The number of farms in California decreased 10% from 2017 to 2022 — according to the US Department of Agriculture census, which it conducts every five years — and the average acreage per farm also decreased by 10%.
“We’re the largest ag state in the country. We grow 65% of the nation’s fruits, vegetables, and tree nuts. But we’re dying on the vine…we’ve lost 25,000 farms in 25 years,” Lunde said in a video. “Nationwide, farmer profits are up 60% in the last decade. In California, down 40%. Why? The cost of doing business in California. Regulatory costs have exploded…California is driving food production out of the state. Just like Hollywood, we’re losing it to other states and countries. So, what is the state doing to lure ag back? Nothing.”
WOE IS ME; WOE IS NOT YOU
Despite being the top agricultural producer in the U.S., California farmers tend to receive a smaller proportion of federal farm subsidies compared to some Midwestern and Southern states. This disparity is partly due to the types of crops grown in California, which are often not the focus of traditional subsidy programs.
On the state side, California agriculture does not have a singular tax credit program akin to the Film and Tax Credit Program, but it does offer a nuanced ecosystem of tax credits, rebates, exemptions, and grant programs for farmers and ranchers.
This includes the Williamson Act, Healthy Soils, and California Competes, amongst others.
However, roughly three months before approving a tax credit increase for Hollywood, the state legislature denied an agricultural request to offset farmworker overtime.
Senate Bill 628, authored by state Senator Shannon Grove, was a proposed tax credit designed to secure opportunities for farmworkers to earn overtime pay while providing relief to struggling agricultural businesses.
The legislation would have counteracted the unintended negative effects of Assembly Bill 1066, which passed in 2016. This overtime bill was fully implemented in 2022, requiring that any work performed by California crop workers exceeding 12 hours in one day be compensated for twice the regular pay rate. Prior to the bill’s passing, California farmworkers received overtime pay for working over 60 hours per week, but the new law changed overtime to over 40 hours.
As such, it cost farm employers more, but farmworkers saw little return, with research indicating that it led to employers cutting hours to manage rising labor costs.
In Hollywood, high labor costs have driven film and television out of California. Hence, the decision to expand the tax incentive program. Similarly, the agricultural industry has faced higher labor and input costs but has received little relief.
According to the California Farm Bureau, a co-sponsor of SB 628, the tax credit would have cost the state budget roughly $200 million to $300 million annually.
“The Legislature elected to ignore our arguments about putting more money in the pockets of farmworkers,” Bryan Little, chief operating officer of Farm Employers Labor Service and senior director of policy advocacy at the California Farm Bureau, told Ag Alert. “It seems hypocritical that we can find $750 million for the Hollywood tax credit, but we can’t find $300 million to do this.”









