Over 200 agriculture groups oppose the agency’s early mitigation strategy.
By Valley Ag Voice Staff
The Environmental Protection Agency is expected to release its 2024 Herbicide Strategy this year, enforcing regulations for agricultural pesticide use to protect endangered species. Opposition to the EPA’s herbicide strategy in favor of protecting listed species has arisen from farmers throughout the nation as the strategy proposes early mitigations for 900 species and critical habitats.
Its strategy is a mixture of population-level protections with a menu of mitigation options to lower the exposure of listed species to ag chemicals through spray drift, runoff, and erosion.
The EPA’s rationale for early mitigation before completing consultations with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is to efficiently utilize their resources in the consultations, thereby expediting their road to compliance.
The draft framework for the strategy was released in July and opened to public comment for 45 days. Rather than focusing on specific herbicides and species, the EPA proposed developing a multi-chemical, multi-species approach in compliance with the ESA’s requirements, specifically on the use of weedkillers.
Roughly 226 ag interest groups and businesses such as the U.S. Department of Agriculture argued that the strategy is overly complex and poses a costly burden on producers. During the comment period, the USDA explained that the herbicide strategy conveys a complex approach to pesticide application that has major implications for farmers and ranchers.
“USDA believes that EPA can protect species and minimize adverse consequences to growers and will be more effective at doing so if sufficient public discussions and engagement opportunities are provided. And we believe many agricultural stakeholders will struggle to make sense of and comply with the complex mitigations described in the framework,” the USDA’s letter said.
The main issue for growers is that the EPA’s framework calls for mitigation measures and “efficacy points” rather than identifying specific requirements to follow. This makes the process of implementing conservation practices tailored to specific regions or crops arduous and expensive.
INTO THE FRAMEWORK
As a result of the Endangered Species Act, the EPA has faced scrutiny from environmental groups for not meeting its requirements in due time, resulting in a long history of legal battles. So, the overly complex herbicide strategy was released to meet the ESA’s requirements and avoid future lawsuits.
With court-mandated deadlines looming over the EPA, the framework it released attempts to encapsulate every region’s pesticide usage and needs with a one-size-fits-all strategy rather than exercising compliance through an individualized pesticide and species approach.
Mitigation strategies include grassed waterways, cover crops, soil incorporation, and water retention systems. However, growers with fields over 1,000 feet away from listed species habitats may be exempt from runoff or erosion mitigation.
Drift mitigation strategies mainly focus on spray drift buffers, the size of which is dependent on application equipment and the level of species impact. Other strategies for runoff and erosion mitigation would assign a value to the chemical, crop, and the listed species in question.
The California Farm Bureau also filed comments with the agency, explaining that the state leads in agricultural production with more than 400 commodities.
“People across the country and around the world rely on California agriculture, as do local economies throughout the state,” CFBF said. “Our growers face unique pest challenges that require complex, time-sensitive decisions about how to protect their crops, while also protecting natural resources and human health. They do this while facing the strictest regulations in the nation.”
The farm bureau also noted that the draft framework does not offer any “mitigation menu options” that are relevant to California growers.
Throughout the 1.12 thousand comments submitted to the EPA, the common consensus is that the strategy is too complex, costly, and imposes significant regulatory burdens for millions of U.S. agriculture producers.
The Center for Biological Diversity also commented on the framework and is notably one of the original plaintiffs who sued the EPA for non-compliance.
“In a few years, there will be an herbicide, fungicide and insecticide strategy in place, and multiple other programmatic frameworks in place as well. What happens when a farmer wants to apply an herbicide, fungicide, and insecticide at the same time? It’s just going to start to get really complicated really quickly,” CBD wrote.
As the EPA reviews multiple public comments, the release date of a formal herbicide strategy is unknown.









