California farm
(Photo: Shutterstock.com)

By Natalie Willis, Reporter, Valley Ag Voice 

In August, the California State Board of Food and Agriculture convened to discuss the current state of economic conditions for farmers and ranchers. From agricultural real estate to ongoing labor issues, industry leaders characterized the challenges confronting California agriculture as well as the financial stakes to stay in business. 

“I wanted to bring this up to our board and just take a look at where our ag industry is today,” board president and Fresno-based farmer Don Cameron said. “I know that there’s a lot of people in my region that are suffering from low commodity prices, lack of equity, declining and putting a lot of growers in some pretty tough situations right now.” 

THE LAND 

The first panel featured a discussion on agricultural land values, presented by Kyle Dalrymple from the California Chapter of the American Society of Farm Managers and Rural Appraisers and Les Crutcher of the Ag Lenders Society of California. 

According to Dalrymple, the state’s agricultural land market is facing a highly challenging environment marked by rising borrowing costs, shrinking commodity prices, and unstable trade conditions.  

“The current state of the agricultural industry in California could be summed up in a single word and that would be challenging,” Dalrymple said. “Now, one could argue that farming has always been challenging, probably always will be challenging. However, the current market environment of 8% to 9% property interest rates, 10% to 13% interest rate operating lines, ever inflating input costs coupled with widespread commodity oversupply, then layered with global trade wars, tariff threats, and [Sustainable Groundwater Management Act] implications has culminated into the severe market retraction with property value decreasing between 10% and 75% broadly.” 

Wine grapes in the Central Valley face some of the steepest losses due to overproduction, weaker demand since COVID-19, and fewer winery contracts which have left thousands of acres unharvested, he explained. The Napa Valley and Central Coast regions have been largely insulated from this decline as they cater to a smaller, high-end market segment.  

For almond orchards in the San Joaquin Valley, values are down 15% to 70% because of depressed commodity prices and challenging global trade conditions. According to Dalrymple, the largest value declines are in groundwater-dependent areas facing SGMA restrictions.  

“Most of the properties that are experiencing 50% or greater value declines are solely reliant on pumped groundwater from overdraft basins,” Dalrymple said. “The Sacramento Valley almond orchards have experienced milder value decreases anywhere from 10% to 40% and that’s due to their greater availability of surface water as well as more resilient groundwater levels.” 

Pistachio values have dipped modestly, mainly in groundwater-only areas, despite strong demand and record harvests. Walnut values, after a 25–65% slide over two years, have stabilized somewhat due to recent price improvements. 

In all, Dalrymple explained that the Sacramento Valley’s cropland values have remained relatively stable due to greater water security. Cropland in the San Joaquin Valley, however, mirrors permanent crop trends where surface water keeps values resilient, but groundwater-only areas have seen steep declines.  

Other sectors are mixed — dairy is relatively stable with decent milk prices and low feed costs, citrus is strong due to limited growing areas, and beef is the standout performer with record prices driven by low herd numbers and low feed costs.  

“The bulk of California’s ag market is currently plagued by elevated borrowing rates, depressed commodity prices across the board, in many cases below the cost of production, as well as turbulent international trade conditions and elevated input costs,” Dalrymple said. “All of this leading to low returns or in many cases, negative returns.” 

Crutcher, representing the Ag Lender Society of California, discussed the financial pressures facing California agriculture, specifically on dairy and almond producers in Merced and Stanislaus counties. These two sectors are central to his company’s lending portfolio. 

“In general, nothing, aside from the cattle market, is overly profitable right now,” Crutcher said. “There’s some break-evens, there’s some positives, and then there’s a few, if not a lot, of negatives out there in the commodities that we’re dealing with overall.” 

He reiterated that almond producers were hit hard by price volatility, dropping from just below $3 per pound to around $2.15-$2.20 after a high crop estimate. Coupled with oversupply, market disruptions, higher input and labor costs, and rising interest rates, these conditions are reducing margins and adding uncertainty to the market.  

THE WATER 

The second panel by Erik Porse of the California Institute of Water Resources and Eddie Ocampo from Water Blueprint for the San Joaquin Valley detailed the financial implications of what continues to be a large elephant in a small room — SGMA.  

While there is no comprehensive study on the financial effects of SGMA, emerging research indicates that it poses potential challenges on land values, reduced productivity and profitability, and increased costs for growers to cover monitoring equipment, consulting fees, and SGMA agency fees. 

According to Porse, it is difficult to isolate SGMA’s effects because agricultural decisions are shaped by several factors, including input costs, cultural background, and water availability. Additionally, the diversity among groundwater sustainability agencies adds to the challenge. 

However, in terms of its financial effects, SGMA can generate a range of new costs for growers. Porse explained that Proposition 218’s requirement to tie fees directly to services complicates how GSAs raise funds, and sometimes fees are applied even to nonproductive land.  

“So, within the Prop 218 context for SGMA, identifying how much you might assess for a fee to implement the projects you’re thinking about, that ends up becoming a cost to producers, to growers in the basin,” Porse said.  

Opportunity costs are also a factor to consider wherein growers are spending time in GSA meetings instead of farming — the core asset business.  

According to Ocampo, his organization — the San Joaquin Valley Water Blueprint — is concerned with the projections that the Valley could lose up to 25% of its irrigated farmland, significantly impacting agriculture-related jobs and businesses.  

Ocampo explained that there are concerns that, with farmland going out of production, there will be an increased dependence on foreign-produced products.  

“We want to make sure that we’re engaging with all levels of community, all levels of stakeholders throughout the valley,” Ocampo said. “We want to identify real estate and how to give more water to the valley when it’s available and how to build up the existing infrastructure of the valley by either improving it or expanding it to make us more capable of being able to grow these resources and these opportunities for future generations.”  

Beyond economic impacts, Ocampo highlighted that agriculture provides deep cultural value to the Central Valley. 

“I think we’ve all heard that we’re going to lose a lot of jobs, potentially lose a lot of revenue, but we can also lose something that’s very important to many of the communities in the valley and something that has been driving all these migratory trends that has made our valley that much more diverse, that much more resilient and just a great place to grow up,” Ocampo said. “We have such diversity, culture, foods, produce, you name it. This has been the result of the opportunity that agriculture has provided.” 

He explained that farming has attracted and sustained diverse immigrant communities over generations, shaping the Valley’s identity, culture, and economy. The loss of agriculture would also mean the loss of that cultural richness. 

THE FARMER 

An agricultural perspective was offered in a panel discussion during the second part of the meeting. 

Alexi Rodriguez of the Almond Alliance explained that California grows 80% of the world’s almonds, and 70% is exported, mainly through the Port of Oakland. However, trade tensions, tariffs, and port challenges have threatened market access, with China dropping from the top buyer list after 2018 tariffs.  

“So, you can imagine our concern when not only our major export markets were threatened with significant tariffs, but we also had Section 301 that proposed shipping fines that could reduce the number of vessels calling on the port of Oakland,” Rodriguez said.  

Current returns for almonds are far below the break-even point, causing billions in annual losses for growers and related businesses.  

“To break even, a grower needs to bring in roughly $2.30 per pound or about $5,000 an acre, and that’s if you have good water and no debt,” Rodriguez said. “However, the 5-year price back to the grower is roughly $1.77 per pound or $3,700 an acre, which conservatively leads to a loss of $1,400 per acre per year for over three years…we’re talking about billions of dollars in losses annually.” 

Because the average cost to plant an orchard is between about $9,000 to $12,000, new plantings have slowed dramatically. To remove an orchard, she explained, is about $3,000 to $4,000 an acre, but most growers are not free from debt or water scarcity, meaning several growers are financially stuck.  

“They can’t plant new orchards, they can’t take care of their existing orchards, and they can’t afford to remove the orchards, which is one of the biggest reasons why we’re seeing a rise in abandoned and unmanaged acreage,” Rodriguez said.  

This abandoned acreage is fueling outbreaks of pests like the navel orange worm, Carpophilus beetle, and rodents — these pests do not respect property lines and affect neighboring farms.  

Thus, the Almond Alliance is pushing for stronger pest prevention partnerships, regulatory impact modeling that reflects cumulative effects, and promotion of almonds’ sustainability achievements. 

“To say that this situation is unsustainable is an extreme understatement, and it’s quickly becoming a generational challenge,” Rodriguez said. “Those that have been farming for generations can no longer afford to keep going…and while we recognize that there are many issues that are occurring simultaneously, we do believe that some of our most effective responses could come from partnership.” 

To stay up to date on State Board of Food and Agriculture meetings or to review recent board actions, visit https://www.cdfa.ca.gov/State_Board/  

Previous articleProposed Water Plan Impacts Supplies 
Next articlePresident’s Message