(Photo: Robert Peak / AdobeStock)

By Natalie Willis, Reporter, Valley Ag Voice 

Central Valley agriculture is often overlooked unless it intersects with political battles — whether it’s water wars, immigration debates, or climate policies. Meanwhile, the industry remains a key economic driver, with California farmers receiving roughly $60 billion in annual cash receipts for their output in 2023, according to the California Department of Food & Agriculture. 

Beyond high-profile policy battles, farmers contend with ongoing challenges that rarely make headlines, such as the farm labor shortage. Further, the industry’s resilience and victories are vital, but are often overlooked in broader discussions. 

THE LABOR ISSUE 

In terms of labor and immigration, which has been a consistent topic in the news cycle since the beginning of 2025, the farm labor shortage in California is not a new issue — it has been a persistent problem for several years. According to a “Farm Labor Issues in the 2020s – Summary Report” by the UC Davis Gifford Center for Population Studies — last updated in April 2024 — California’s farm labor shortage is driven by a shrinking immigrant workforce, stricter immigration policies, rising labor costs, competition from other industries, and a declining interest in agricultural work among younger generations. 

Further, while recent U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement activity in Kern County incited fear in the farmworker community, reports that farmworkers stopped coming to work as a result of the operation are largely unfounded.  

“While there have been news reports of unease among some farm employees, the California Farm Bureau has been in contact with numerous farmers across the state and has not heard of any widespread workforce disruption,” a California Farm Bureau Federation press release stated.  

The press release explained that while concerns exist, farmers are continuing operations, and the Farm Bureau has not received reports indicating otherwise.  

Even as these labor challenges persist, many farmers are adapting by investing in mechanization and seeking reforms to the H-2A agricultural visa program. According to a 2019 CFBF survey, more than half of surveyed farmers and ranchers reported adopting mechanization, with 56% citing employee shortages as the primary factor. However, only about 6% of surveyed farmers enrolled in the H-2A agricultural visa program due to its inefficiencies. 

“Through the years, the H-2A program has proven inadequate for farms in California and throughout the nation,” CFBF President Jamie Johansson said in a release. “Farm Bureau will continue to work with Congress to create a secure, flexible, market-based immigration program that works better for both farmers and farm employees.” 

One of the most discussed policy proposals to address agricultural labor shortages is the Farm Workforce Modernization Act. The bill, which has previously passed the House of Representatives but failed to advance in the Senate, seeks to provide a legal pathway to citizenship for undocumented farmworkers while also reforming the H-2A visa program to allow for year-round employment. 

Although U.S. Representative Dan Newhouse told Ag Information Network of the West his intent to reintroduce the bill in the current Congress, the measure has yet to be formally introduced, and its prospects remain unclear. 

Still, the ability of farmers to adapt — whether through mechanization or shifting market strategies — has played a role in shaping production trends and commodity market stability. 

SIGNS OF STRENGTH 

While labor shortages continue to be a concern for the agricultural industry, commodity markets are showing signs of resilience.  

According to research from Rabobank’s Food and Agribusiness, the state’s almond industry is eyeing a significant recovery. Rabobank’s Five-year Almond Market Outlook explained that almond prices are expected to rebound over the next 12 to 18 months despite global production returning to higher levels.  

California plays a critical role in determining the state of the almond market as it accounts for roughly 80% of global almond production and about 86% of global almond exports, the report explained. While production challenges hindered the industry in 2022 and 2023, a lower carry-in from 2024 set the stage for potential price stabilization at stronger levels. Carry-ins refer to the amount of unsold almond inventory from the previous marketing year that carries over into the new marketing year. 

According to Rabobank, the average estimate for 2024/25 carry-in is just under 500 million pounds — a significant drop from the 800-million-pound-plus carry-ins of the last two seasons. 

“The expected lower carry-in has already begun to strengthen pricing, and this change in supply-side ‘starting position’ gives us a strong backdrop for price recovery, even though the 2024 crop could be significantly larger than the past two seasons,” the report stated.  

The outlook expects almond prices to continue to strengthen, with an average price estimate at $2.15 per pound — considering additional supply and demand elements and risk, the report provides a 50% probability that prices land between $1.85 and $2.45 per pound.  

For context, this range signals an improvement over recent years when prices hovered near break-even levels for many growers. 

Similarly, the walnut industry is poised for a shift, with acreage expected to decline as the market moves toward greater stability. 

According to David Magaña, Horticulture Senior Analyst at Rabobank. Magaña explained that walnut acreage in California is likely to continue declining, mainly driven by profitability challenges as well as water regulations and restrictions. 

“There is a significant change in the global market, and given all the challenges experienced a few years ago, now we’re expecting, or already seeing, acreage in California being flat to declining,” Magaña said.  

According to Rabobank’s global walnut market update, U.S. walnut shipments have reached record levels in terms of volume and the California walnut industry’s emphasis on marketing has expanded the market.  

“Instead of merely supplying an ingredient commodity, the industry is transitioning to building value. This includes forging value-added partnerships across retail and food service channels as well as with food manufacturers,” the report stated.  

Magaña noted that while inputs and logistics are in a better position for growers so far this year, there are still unknowns due to the possibility of inflation and tariffs.  

“Just the tariffs, the additional 10% on products coming from China, that will be impacting all the farming goods coming from China, so the cost is likely to go up again,” Magaña said. “It’s kind of a wait and see if more tariffs are going to be implemented — we don’t know at the moment.” 

For more information on Rabobank’s Food and Agribusiness Research, visit their website at https://www.raboag.com/. Local experts in agricultural research post reports on a consistent basis, providing insights on market trends, sustainability, and industry developments to help farmers and agribusinesses make informed decisions. 

Previous articleThe Trout’s Sign is Back Home! 
Next articlePumping 1/100th of Available Water: A Case Study in Regulatory Constraints